How can you tell?

Mar 09, 2021,12:44 PM
 

Hi,

How can you tell between metal and silicon?

Thanks,
Chi Kai

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Breguet. La Tradition - silicone spring?

 
 By: Humanist : March 9th, 2021-07:11
Every description I have found says the Cal. 507xx has silicone springs. My early one does not look like it. Can one tell from the picture? Where earlier ones non silicone? Thank you for your help. ...  

Silicone or silicium ? I have a big doubt... 🤔

 
 By: Mike H : March 9th, 2021-11:00
Whatever the spring it is a great watch 👍👏👏

How can you tell?

 
 By: chikai168 : March 9th, 2021-12:44
Hi, How can you tell between metal and silicon? Thanks, Chi Kai

They look different, so appearance is the first clue.

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : March 9th, 2021-14:07
I can say with the Breguet movements, the watches' stated accuracy ranges improve after the move to silicon, so looking for things like that can give another clue. Hope that helps!

I would say, metal based ones look silver /-ish, silicone blue or black and have a more "perfect" appearance.

 
 By: Humanist : March 9th, 2021-15:21
There is not much doubt that silicone might be more accurate, but so are quartz movements. We love mechanical watches for other reasons than accuracy. Both Philippe Dufour and the late George Daniels rejected silicone springs. Both for the main reason tha... 

Cheers!

 
 By: chikai168 : March 11th, 2021-15:37

Thanks!

 
 By: chikai168 : March 11th, 2021-15:38

The answer from Breguet:

 
 By: amanico : March 10th, 2021-09:21
" In 2006, Breguet introduced its first wristwatches with silicon balance spring and escapement. It combines the advantages and qualities of the earlier experiments. Silicon also possesses advantages of its own. Silicon is totally impervious to magnetic f... 

Thank you Nico,

 
 By: Humanist : March 10th, 2021-13:16
So I am very, very happy to have a 2005 "La Tradition", the traditional one with metal spring Thanks for helping

Yes, you can feel lucky.

 
 By: amanico : March 10th, 2021-13:18