I bought a steel Fifty Fathoms Bathyscape, perfect Blancpain, 43mm for my 7 inch wrist, under the radar, very accurate. Best one as far as I am concerned, not too pricey compared to the others.
but I might have considered it if it was out then. Although I'm lucky if my wrist is 6.5" so I might have still preferred the Hodinkee. Size aside they are both very cool looking 50 Fathoms. I prefer no date but like how they did it on that new option.
I am a fan of the Bathyscaphe but also the 42.3mm Fifty Fathoms. I think that is a watch with incredible ergonomics and is worth your time. That said, if you are tempted by the Bathyscaphe, go for that. My ceramic one is 43.6mm and wears like a dream. If ...
You must try on as many models as you can at your AD/boutique. They will look and feel different live and on the wrist, and what you thought appealed to you in theory may be completely different from what truly enamours you.