When ALS first notified me about the 'oxidation', and I did not have the benefit of the pictures, I thought they were just random specks which I was totally ok with. I am perfectly fine with patina-ed/ imperfect dials, but a lot of love I have for this watch centers on the dial - so cool, even austere, definitely teutonic and very ALS. I don't think I can look at the dial without getting distracted by the oxidation so a new dial it would have to be.