MartinGreen
28
The Netherlands/US
Feb 17, 2010,10:43 AM
Overall I think Piaget is still on top of it's game, but personally there where a couple of things that have a certain impact on me as a consumer. Please forgive my direct and very personal opinion and keep in mind that I have yet to see most of them in real life.
Starting with the Altiplano's; 43mm is way too large for an ultrathin watch. Blancpain did something like this a couple of years ago with their Villeret time only. Makes the watch look like a saucer that misses it's cup. Also the spacer has to be too large. I liked the way Piaget handled that since it didn't really bother me, but smaller is nicer. Also disliked the word automatic on the dial. Too big, too prominent and it does not add anything.
The diamond version is quite stunning. I love the diamond setting on the bridges!
The Altiplano Double Jeu was never my favorite because I dislike the crowns on two different heights. The 24 hour dial is too plain. It reminds me of a Russian Vostok that was made for the Russians polar explorations. This is not a bad thing because it is very legible, but I would love to see a more jazzed up version; black dial with red numerals would add some more character. Also think I would prefer black hands, since a 24 hour dial already takes a bit more time to read and sink in, the silver hands are too difficult to spot.
I love the FortyFive but this is too much for me. Very busy and the truly interesting parts of the movement still stay hidden. Think the gold tone parts of the movement are out of place and this watch takes time to read. Same goes for the FortyFive automatic, although that one maintains it's easy to read nature.
White looks great on many magnificent cars, but on watches I think it still looks cheap. Fortunately my wife agrees with me. But when I'm not mistaken there is also a black model, so no further complains.
The Emperadors are stunning, beautiful design, simple, elegant, yet very powerful. Hands on the cloisonne enamel dial are a no no for me. Love the hands on the other one though and think that they will suit the first one perfectly aswel.
The last three ladies watches are what Piaget is all about to me! Absolutely superb!! Elegant, playful yet never a toy. One request; make the Magic Hour also in a men's version!!!
Martin
Comments:
view entire thread
What do YOU think? And your country location?
By: MTF : January 26th, 2010-23:26
Dear forumners, Now that the dust has settled, and before the official PuristSPro SIHH 2010 Report, I am interesed to hear what YOU think of the PIAGET introductions this year? Not just from the regular posters but everyone that checks in. Even if you wis...
Singapore
By: MTF : January 26th, 2010-23:27
My opinions already posted but I wanted to start the country count! MTF
USA
By: DRMW : January 26th, 2010-23:37
I thought it was a good showing by PIAGET for things to come in 2010. The FortyFive are too big for my small wrists but the Altiplano skeleton is still my favorite. I know that PIAGET has a history of watchmaking and desire to reclaim that position, but c...
Belgium ...
By: bimbeano : January 27th, 2010-00:37
Altiplano .... is THE Piaget for me ... . Filip
Croatia
By: Ares501 - Mr Green : January 27th, 2010-01:18
Ref. G0A35174 Limelight Jazz Party Polo Tourbillon Relatif. absolute best Piaget in show for me Regards Damian
Boston
By: aaronm : January 27th, 2010-08:03
(We don't like to think of ourselves as part of the USA) I like the new automatics conceptually, and the new movement is quite nice looking, but I think 43mm is way too big fo that A
So, I see......
By: MTF : January 27th, 2010-09:18
aaron, I guess youse guys didn't get along with anyone....see Founding Fathers vs George and how to spoil a tea party. But you have good taste in watches..... Regards, MTF
USA
By: AnthonyTsai : January 27th, 2010-08:43
I like the new Polo FortyFive changes. I was hoping that there would be a complication expansion to the Polo FortyFive line-up, so I hope maybe next year we'll see a Polo FortyFive perpetual or something of that sorts. Also, I was hoping to see the Polo F...
Both
By: kevster : January 28th, 2010-07:18
I like the red on the dial as well.
Taiwan
By: lien : January 27th, 2010-23:55
i like women's line a lot more as they r simply exquisite but i would only considering them for a grand gift to the significant one The new Polo is a step forward but i feel they r still more of trying to impress than a completely matured model. having sa...
Immaturity.....sigh
By: MTF : January 28th, 2010-15:39
lien, Ahh....sigh. Quote: "The new Polo is a step forward but i feel they r still more of trying to impress than a completely matured model." I guess that for a 136-year old company, a 30-year old model may be immature. Thanks for feedback. Regards, MTF
Hmmm...
By: lien : January 28th, 2010-20:01
Hi MTF, The new Polo i m referring to the 45, is very well made, a new dandy sport watch. but then i learned a bit more about Piaget here and now, big dial tag advertising its a fly back/second time zone and now with heavy paints, skeletonized dial works....
USA
By: dxboon : January 28th, 2010-01:18
I love the new regular production 43mm Altiplano. I also think the 2010 Polo FortyFive is very promising. It's going to get a second look from me for sure. Cheers, Daos
USA...
By: Dino944 : January 29th, 2010-13:21
I was very impressed with Piaget's Altiplano offerings this year. I particularly like the anniversary model and the 43mm with 1208P movement. For many years I was sure the only Piaget I'd want to get would be an Emperador...but now I think I'd much prefer...
Where are the Canadians?
By: MTF : January 29th, 2010-19:26
Seduced by Force? Enigmatic title: explained. I don't know why but every time I see that Wookie, I think of Nanook of the North (1922). And every time I think of Nanook.....Canadians! Regards, MTF
Currently in Japan.
By: Davo : January 30th, 2010-02:04
But originally from New Zealand. Konnichiwa... and Kia ora! Oh and BTW, I really like the new Polo Forty-5 Chrono. IMO, it's the best looking Piaget they've ever released. Hope to see more like it in future.
Australia
By: bill2016 : February 1st, 2010-06:16
My opinion of Piagets' introductions this year could be summed up in one word: Extraordinary. I have always been a fan of ultra thins and I am really glad about Piagets' new 1200P and 1208P movements. Aesthetically, I am deeply impressed by the new Altipl...
USA
By: ED209 : February 2nd, 2010-17:53
Altiplano for me. Regards, ED-209
London
By: vernon : February 3rd, 2010-10:07
I have always liked the 'ultra-thin' watches (although I don't own one) and applaud Piaget for maintaining the tradition of producing them. I like the hand wound versions, both the good old 38mm version and the newer 40mm version with the offset seconds. ...
I agree that 40mm is perfect to
By: MTF : February 4th, 2010-03:40
emphasise the thin movement. They can't really do 38mm because this is a large diameter movement (1208P). We can only plead as fans for the real deal......40mm.....40mm....40mm........ MTF
Malaysia
By: ling5hk : February 5th, 2010-16:29
Atiplano suits my taste. When I am getting older, I favour simpler stuff. Regards Ling
The Netherlands/US
By: MartinGreen : February 17th, 2010-10:43
Overall I think Piaget is still on top of it's game, but personally there where a couple of things that have a certain impact on me as a consumer. Please forgive my direct and very personal opinion and keep in mind that I have yet to see most of them in r...
Magic for Men
By: MTF : February 17th, 2010-18:58
Martin, Magic Hour for Men....hmm....there's a thought. I did ask about the feaibility of a mechanicl movement Magic Hour and it is impossible with current in-house Piaget movements, due to the twisting case action. I don't see them making a backside wind...
