Topcat30093
3482
Two great choices.................
I have the 5205G and love it.
The apertures are nicely located and are not covered by the hands, as they are more often with the 5396R. The case of the 5205G is lovely crafted and has the new :Torpedo" style lugs (my terminology) due to the concave style of the case, the 5205 sits higher off the wrist than the 5396.
The watch is very comfortable to wear.
The only negative that I have, is at times and in certain light the legibility of the hands can be a bit difficult.
Are you looking at the plain dial or railway track 5396?
Which ever piece you choice...............You can't loose.
Regards
Tony
Available on the marketplace
2,889 Patek Philippe listings are live on the eBay market and 1722 collector listings on the WatchProSite marketplace.
5205G or 5396R
Considering one of these two pieces and wonder if owners of these two have opinions of how they like them in comparison to each other and also comfort feel on a rather small to average wrist size. Thanks for your opinions.
Two great choices.................
I have the 5205G and love it. The apertures are nicely located and are not covered by the hands, as they are more often with the 5396R. The case of the 5205G is lovely crafted and has the new :Torpedo" style lugs (my terminology) due to the concave style ...
Readability a real problem?
Hi Tony, I was just about to get a 5205G but have seen some of the readability concerns. How bad is it? Do you have problems telling the time in a dimly lit restaurant, for example?
Definitely the 5205G.
It has much nicer look in my eyes and a bigger which is a nice plus too.
Good choices!
I have the 5396R with the first-generation "scientific" dial, which I think is stunning. I waited to see if the 5205 was going to be released in rose gold at Basel 2012, and now I know it isn't, I have put a deposit down on the black dial 5205G. I am a gr...
Same conclusion but...
discovering the 2 new versions of the 5396, I had an heart attack on both : blue dial on white gold case and chocolate dial on rose gold case. But (again), there are launched only with bracelet. Arrrgh ! So I must wait until Patek furnish them with a leat...
5396R is a classic !
IMHO 5396 in rose gold and white dial is an ultimate classic... 5205 is a modern version with better readability of apertures but I just do not appreciate the dial colour combos...grey and darker versions of it are a serious put off for me. So will wait t...
swjoseph, that is a stunning photo...........
And is giving me the itch to wear mine Regards Tony
PP5205G OR 5396G
The PP5396G has the typical Patek vintage look . Whilst the PP5205G is more retro and a modern look which may not go well with the general Patek community.Personally I will go for the PP5396. The latter is very Patek. ad could have passed off as the PP512...
5205G
Modern looking annual calendar with instant calendar aperture and combo dial with pierced lugs and concave bezel. It is an elegantly original dress watch for the new Patek model.
both are great...
but I bought the 5396R because it is more classic Patek and I wanted a rose gold on the other hand, 5205 is more stylish so it depends on what are the more important objectives for you you will enjoy either good luck !!
I think its impossible to go wrong in this case
One could easily argue that all three watches could fit very nicely in a collection. My personal favorite is the first gen 5396R
i chose 5205
I went throng the same dilemma. decided on 5205. More readable, beautiful case. Just received deployant clasp, feels much safer. At the end it is very personal. Both are great watches.
Tough choice........
My father-in-law has both pieces so I've handled them both many times. For me, as nice as the 5205g is it would be hard for me to pass up the 5396r. It may be one of the nicest Patek's currently made. Good luck with your decision! Tony