Marcus Hanke
[PuristSPro Moderator]
11296
Interesting comment, about the zodiax spirit ...
... I had not thought about that, but you are right: a Chinese zodiac motif should capture the spirit attributed to the animal, while the PP - its artistic qualities being beyond question - rather is a zoological textbook illustration.
Marcus
Year of the Snake comparion - Patek vs Ulysse
which one do you guys like more ? very different interpretation of the same motif between Patek (marquetry) and Ulysse (champlev) of the same Chinese zodiac...
Year of the Snake comparion - Patek vs Ulysse
Stylistically and artistically, the UN is more ornate than the PP, as usual. My guess is that this will determine most individuals' preference. However, from a Chinese calender perspective, I think the UN series captures the spirit of the Chinese zodiac b...
Interesting comment, about the zodiax spirit ...
... I had not thought about that, but you are right: a Chinese zodiac motif should capture the spirit attributed to the animal, while the PP - its artistic qualities being beyond question - rather is a zoological textbook illustration. Marcus
Neither.....
Unfortunately these historiated dials, despite my appreciation of the artistry behind, are not if my taste. Mo
Patek's interpretation gets my vote.
Though the UN has that "Wow!" factor over patek's, i do think that i will get bored with it easily. Patek's interpretation is much more restrained and cultured, subtle and artistic - a mimicry of nature at its finest! This is of course just my opinion. Al...
Year of the Snake
I must say the snake is a tough subject. Of the two, I'd probably opt for the Patek. Vacheron Constantin has one with a mini sculpture combined with enameling on the dial. But again, for aesthetics, I defer to Martin Pauli and his miniature paintings: Dea...
Thank you all for your comments...overall result...
... based on the same post in Patek and Ulysse forums is that it is pretty much a tie for Patek's marquetry snake and Ulysse's champlevé snake