I think from a technical perspective the Rolex has a better bracelet, bezel and is more durable. The PP has a much cleaner dial and prettier backside.
Your pictures do not do the yatch master justice though. It looks much better in real life and I think is just reflecting back to much in the picture.
If price is no issue, go PP.
If you are going to bang it around on a beach, Rolex.
Just my 2cents