Worth the trade?

Jul 14, 2018,10:32 AM
 

Patek 5712 for AP 15202IP?


More posts: 5712nautilus

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Nope!

 
 By: sham1 : July 14th, 2018-10:45
No Patek should be traded for an AP especially a 5712. Nothing to do with resale values either. A Patek in my opinion is in a different league in every area - movement finishing, case size, case thinness, lovely micro rotor, but if the AP appeals to you m... 

Agree on all points! [nt]

 
 By: CastorKrieg : July 14th, 2018-10:55

YES!

 
 By: Joepny : July 14th, 2018-12:14
15202IP has the more interesting material and finish. Titanium and platinum. The smoked blue dial is gorgeous. Complementary date wheel. Beautiful Royal Oak bracelet brushed finish. I am a big fan of the mirror polished bezel. Only 250 made. I think the r... 

5712 should never be traded...

 
 By: Alex83 : July 15th, 2018-03:15
If you bought it in first place I understand that you like it... This is a keeper. Better to save for the 15202IP or trade another one... Now, between the 5711 or the 15202 I do prefer the Royal Oak.

+1

 
 By: 1WatchMan : July 15th, 2018-05:02
But if you like the 15202, go for it, that's the most powerful reason to go for a watch 😉

Remember Motley Fool?

 
 By: jonrus : July 15th, 2018-05:18
The saying was... in every deal, who is the bigger fool? In this trade deal, the owner of the 5712 is the bigger fool. Don’t do it.