amanico
[JLC Moderator]
404863
Montblanc × Collective Horology 1858 Minerva Monopusher Chronograph “Blue Arrow”
Montlblanc just unveiled a new version of the 1858 Red Arrow, issued in 2022, which I reviewed here.
This year, Montblanc issued a small series of 1858 Minerva mono pusher with a blue arrow this time for an US retailer " Collectiv Horology. Same steel case proportions ( 42 mm / circa 13 mm high ), same bezel, same movement, of course... The only thing which changes is the dial and the use of the good old Minerva logo at 6 o' clock, plus the two sub dials in a creamy color, like if Time offered them patina.
And there is something else I quite regret... The fact that the dial is not enameled, but lacquered. This version is 10% more expensive than the " Red Arrow ". It could be 10% more for an enamel dial, it would be better.
And as we are at it... Why not a tad smaller case? 40 mm would be perfect.
And as we are at it... Why not a tad smaller case? 40 mm would be perfect.
The superb movement, Cal 13.21 would be less lost!
And well, 33 pieces... That doesn't make sense.
And well, 33 pieces... That doesn't make sense.
Now, the biggest problem I have is the patina of the two subdials.
What do you think?
Best,
Nicolas
Available on the marketplace
Collection
Explore the Montblanc 1858 collection's Minerva heritage and design with jrwong23. Discover the Calibre 16.29 Chronograph Tachymeter and Small Seconds.
45 replies20255 views
Reference Guide
Explore the Montblanc 1858 Minerva Monopusher Chronograph Red Arrow. Amanico's review compares this 2022 release to its vintage ancestor, detailing design, movement, and collector insights.
40 replies16183 views
Complications
Explore the Montblanc 1858 Unveiled Secret Minerva Monopusher Chronograph from Watches and Wonders 2022. Amanico reviews its innovative movement display.
64 replies14789 views
Review
Jrwong23 reviews the Montblanc 1858 Tachymeter Chronograph Steel with blue dial, focusing on the Minerva Calibre 16.29 movement and its craftsmanship.
32 replies13163 views
Discussion
Revisit Watches and Wonders 2022 with 'amanico's' expert review of Patek Philippe, Rolex, JLC, and more. Discover key releases and collector insights.
38 replies11223 views
New Release
Montblanc SIHH 2014 novelties in Singapore: jrwong23 reviews Meisterstück Heritage Perpetual Calendar, Homage to Nicolas Rieussec, and TimeWalker Extreme Chronograph DLC. Discover Montblanc's new direction.
39 replies9917 views
Montblanc × Collective Horology 1858 Minerva Monopusher Chronograph “Blue Arrow”
Montlblanc just unveiled a new version of the 1858 Red Arrow, issued in 2022, which I reviewed here. This year, Montblanc issued a small series of 1858 Minerva mono pusher with a blue arrow this time for an US retailer " Collectiv Horology. Same steel ca...
I generally love these, but
I’m not crazy about the dial color scheme. That said, readability looks very good.
It’s that blue color that’s
not working for me. Im in agreement with you on the sub dial color 👍
The yellow color is supposedly not faux patina, but was used on at least one vintage Minerva stopwatch, according to H-
I found a model with yellow subdial on a popular auction site, not sure whether it can be shared here. If interested, Google minerva n468. No idea whether it is correct or whether other models exist. Maybe, some Minerva expert can clarify.
I was not a fan
I don't like the color scheme. In addition, I agree on size... why not 40mm? The "ring" around the movement that says P5 and fait a villeret is unnecessary. Reduce the size of the case by that amount and you should be spot on. I do like that strap, very c...
I wanted to love it, but like you the size of the movement in that case is off for me, also…
Personally I would have made the minutes and hour hands darker for this white dial…
Not for me, reasons are...
1. Solid black numeric markers is hard to blend in a pastel -colored dial. 2. White gold fluted bezel has lost its charm against a light-colored dial. 3. Agreed that the movement is a tad small for the case but both the red arrow and the unveiled secret h...
I am biased about my first impression and do not mean to offend anyone...
For the Red Arrow I would just feel 'wow with awe' whereas this one ' what's going on here ? 'Off white enamel dial would make a difference to me.
Not for me
The size should be 40mm and 42mm I feel left too much open space that is hard to ignore. I am ok with the colors on the dial and sub dials though. But I don't like them using two logos in front. Minerva and Montblanc. In fact, I'll rather they don't have ...
Subdial color is a little unconventional…
I thought at first they might have been lumed. An unexpected color and I can’t say I’ve entirely warmed up to them, but I could see how experiencing the watch in the metal could totally elevate my opinion. In general I think it’s a good looking watch that...
I kind of like the color codes
but I am with you, enamel is a must with a white dial from Minerva with this layout
Maybe too expensive...
... in any case well over my price range, so not a real problem for me. For who may be interested: wornandwound.com ;
