He seems to be going down the sports watch line

Jan 07, 2024,18:24 PM
 

Which is popular, but not sure the MB collector is clamoring for. Oddly that line is called montblanc 1858 collection , of which 1858 was the founding of what became minerva. This is curious because minerva wasn't making sports watches! Even more odd is that collection villeret 1858 is the lineup where the fine haute horology pieces were titled, so why name the sports watch so closely. The collectors of these pieces may become annoyed or disheartened, and the people coming in for $ 2k sports watch don't usually know or care of this history (and if they do know of minerva and 1858 they know it doesn't pertain to sports watches so there is no benefit here).

In addition they had some overlap where their heritage lines looked the same as different minerva variants. All in all, a lot of added confusion and movement away from the high end pieces we all love. I'm no marketing person, but feel the brand confusion and lack of clear branding and brand association with the villeret workshops will hurt. I think 2 years ago everything was sold out quickly, with a softening watch market and collector seeking brands that emphasize excellence- there may be some trouble. Additionally montblanc seems to be a stepping stone for these directors to another place so they are focused on cheap ways to increase sales not connoisseur level brand integrity 🤷‍♂️


More posts: 1858 CollectionCollection Villeret

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Big fan of the manual winds!

 
 By: jchu147 : January 7th, 2024-00:15
Nicolas Rieussec 104981. Dial’s a bit busy but still loving it ...  

Lovely rieussec

 
 By: TeutonicCarFan : January 7th, 2024-00:22
I'm hoping they come out with a 40🤷‍♂️

Me too!

 
 By: jchu147 : January 7th, 2024-00:25

Always admired them

 
 By: Horology75 : January 7th, 2024-07:38

+1

 
 By: hora12reborn : January 7th, 2024-14:44

Yep.

 
 By: amanico : January 7th, 2024-17:42

Big failure of Jerome to kill this model

 
 By: penfriend : January 7th, 2024-16:06
Much too early but he wanted no others success around him…

Too bad, indeed.

 
 By: amanico : January 7th, 2024-17:42

He seems to be going down the sports watch line

 
 By: TeutonicCarFan : January 7th, 2024-18:24
Which is popular, but not sure the MB collector is clamoring for. Oddly that line is called montblanc 1858 collection , of which 1858 was the founding of what became minerva. This is curious because minerva wasn't making sports watches! Even more odd is t... 

good summary!

 
 By: penfriend : January 7th, 2024-18:52
Even though the hh line was called 1858 "vintage" this small difference has never been explained. Their brand management and marketing is a big miss I must admit.

Indeed confusion

 
 By: TeutonicCarFan : January 7th, 2024-19:18
Even here I have seen villeret 1858, villeret 1858 vintage and collection villeret 1858. The nomenclature is difficult as I'm not sure all journalists have been implementing this accurately as well.

Beautiful !

 
 By: Wachnut : January 7th, 2024-15:48
Didn’t know they had manuals ! Mine is the original automatic , but I prefer your manual 😊 ...