A bit late to the party: Swatch Sistem51 review/overview

Jan 27, 2014,18:29 PM
 


The Sistem51 is probably the most interesting watch introduced at Basel 2013, unfortunately it's not until almost SIHH 2014 that we actually saw the watch come on sale in Switzerland.

I've obtained a few and here are my impressions: (disclaimer, I purchased these for resale but will attempt to maintain neutrality in this overview).


The watch, like the iPhone 5C, can be said to be "unapologetically plastic" both inside and out. The watch is almost ironic because of how it satisfies many haute horologerie requirements. There is no dust whatsoever inside the watch, it's immaculate. The escapement is held by a full bridge and is even "free sprung" (but not variable inertia). Adjustment is quite good with amplitude around 270 degrees and a promised 5 second accuracy, presumably on the wrist. I found it was +10 vertical and spot on flat.


The watch features 90 hours of power reserve, this is partly due to the 21.6k vph frequency, precision lubrication and assembly by machine only, and plastic escapement that is likely both light and self lubricating.


A few unusual review notes: 

The rotor is undirectional (clockwise winding) and seems to rely on a very high gear ratio since the oscillating weight is plastic.

Hand winding is possible, but it requires turning the crown an unusual counterclockwise.

There is an ETA stamp on both the watch itself as well as the movement.

The movement does not hack

Date change occurs between 11:30 and 1:00 am

Different colours come on different straps. The white version comes on a plain silicon strap, while the black comes on a apparently leather strap, and the red one comes on a stitched silicon strap.

Straps are much more comfortable than I expected.

The rotor sounds a bit loose when shaken, but all 6 I have here have the same sound.

The rotor gives a kind of lightweight but noticeable "Valjoux wobble" when rotating counterclockwise.

Escapement is louder than most watches, probably due to the plastic casing.


Enjoy the photos below!










*My wrist is 6.25" and quite flat


This message has been edited by Ed. W on 2014-01-27 18:33:11











  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Thanks Ed!

 
 By: KIH : January 27th, 2014-19:26
Now I know what the fuss is about this "Sistem 51" stuff, thanks to your review and very nice photos. No wonder many people are talking about this. Congrats! Interesting indeed. Ken

Glad I could help

 
 By: Ed. W : January 29th, 2014-19:55
It'll be interesting to see where this technology goes.

What is the significance of the pattern...

 
 By: craniotes : January 27th, 2014-21:12
...of dots on the dial? This far it seems that every version shares a variation of the same theme. Regards, Adam

Accuracy.

 
 By: SteveW : January 28th, 2014-00:01
Anecdotal, of course. After the first week of wearing mine was around -5 seconds. It would probably have been closer if I hadn't worn it to bed the first night, when I found the next morning that it had lost 7 seconds over the whole day. The rest of the w... 

thanks for the review Ed

 
 By: G99 : January 30th, 2014-01:45
it wasnt anything i wasnt expecting so i was happy to pull the plug on a red one last night from France rather than wait until they eventually get to the UK. i got it for a price that i consider is about the same as the UK watches will be once they add th... 

Are there any...

 
 By: BDLJ : January 30th, 2014-17:18
...images or links you can share with details of the balance spring and plastic escapement? Thank you for the update, too.

"Almost ironic", I like this expression! ...

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : January 31st, 2014-03:33
What I don't like is the watch's rejection of sustainability, which should be a key factor in mechanical watches. It cannot be opened, it cannot be serviced, when the plastic breaks, you throw away the watch. Marcus

This is an excellent point

 
 By: ei8htohms : January 31st, 2014-10:06
This watch singlehandedly undermines all three of the only defensible reasons to own a mechanical watch: craftsmanship, longevity and prestige. It's a dangerous game they're playing. _john

I agree this is only the begining

 
 By: Ed. W : January 31st, 2014-21:48
but what if they could make a watch that was serviceable but do so completely automated. Or perhaps even apply fine finishes without human intervention. I think it's not really a question of if but rather of when. This wouldn't be so dissimilar to the mov... 

we can't fight the future

 
 By: ei8htohms : January 31st, 2014-22:03
New technologies will change us no matter how we resist. That said, folks still make tube amps, folks still press vinyl records, folks still make mech watches. Time will tell which directions are fruitful and which are dead ends. _john