Moka-Tiger (Ron)
1654
Which dial among 2 Classique models??
I am going crazy trying to decide between 2 watches: the RG "Automatique" and the "Lune".
.
I prefer simple dials with easy-to-read time, so the Autmatique with blue hands and black numbers, without the "lune function" should be an easy choice. I sense that the blue hands/black numbers are THE classic Journe look. But, then, I keep wondering if the dial on the Automatique, without the lune function, looks too bare? Plus, the blue hands/numbers are pretty standard compared to the shiny gold hands and applied numbers on the Lune model. I noticed that the gold creates a much more dressy feel and luxurious look. And the lune function fills in the dial.
It's so hard to choose when all the watches are beautiful and only 1 is possible.
Actually, I chose one already and am now debating whether to choose the other one instead.
I will make the final decision in the end, when I get there.
After buying yours, do you Journe owners have any thoughts about my comments on these 2 watches?
Thanks in advance for any input.
(Pics from Journe website for showing the 2 watches.)
Below: Automatique
Below: Lune
Available on the marketplace
63 F.P. Journe listings are live on the eBay market and 270 collector listings on the WatchProSite marketplace.
Independents
ChristianDK reviews the F.P. Journe Paris Boutique experience, showcasing Octa Automatique Lune models, staff insights, and new slimmer 40mm bezels.
52 replies20509 views
Collection
Experience the thrill of unboxing an F.P. Journe Octa Lune Salmon Dial. King of the Road shares his passion for this unique timepiece and its evolving features.
67 replies12113 views
Manufacture
ChristianDK tours the renovated F.P. Journe Paris Boutique. Explore its elegant design, natural light, and unique exhibition spaces, with insights on watch sizes and strap options.
48 replies8840 views
Manufacture
Explore the F.P. Journe Tokyo boutique experience. Pulp84 shares insights on watch sizing, brand aesthetic, and community views on 38mm vs. 40mm cases.
50 replies8829 views
Reference Guide
Explore the F.P. Journe Octa Divine Lune 36mm's rare transitional features, including case and movement variations. A must-read for collectors.
38 replies8492 views
Lifestyle
Explore how a strap change transforms the F.P. Journe Octa Lune and dive into the critical discussion on aftermarket strap spring bar quality and material for precious metal watches.
39 replies7856 views
Which dial among 2 Classique models??
I am going crazy trying to decide between 2 watches: the RG "Automatique" and the "Lune". . I prefer simple dials with easy-to-read time, so the Autmatique with blue hands and black numbers, without the "lune function" should be an easy choice. I sense th...
Agreed.
This is DEFINITELY a 'no wrong answers' situation... but I really love the intentional use of empty dial space on the Octa dial, and that's at its strongest in the Automatique.
The lune for sure.
Power reserve alone is taking too much space. The moonphase is a welcoming and cool complicatiom. For me clearly the second one 🤗
From a visual point I prefer the Automatique.
I like the use of empty space in that model.
I agree that empty space is a good thing.
In Japan where I live, space is traditionally a part of good design. In this case, though, I opted for the moonphase Lune because I don't have one.
Between these two…
That’s a lot of red gold with case and dial. The blue of the Lune adds some contrast to it. And I have taken a liking to the added numerals. Lune for me.
In the rose gold, I would choose the Lune.
Good luck getting an allocation. Sold out for a while I hear.
Take the Lune.
Because If You ended up bought the non-Lune Then You willat some point feel like You should have got the Lune. I have bought the Octa RG Lune with the newest moon version(nasa) I feel that I have made super good decision! Trust me, Go for the Lune. You wi...
I totally agree.
I first chose the Automatique and then went back and forth trying to decide if I made the right decision for me. I finally decided on the Lune and haven't looked back.
Get whichever one they offer you first
Can't go wrong with either. There are "pros" and "cons" in both, and truth be told they are not real "pros" nor "cons" as it's just down to personal preferences, which vary hugely from person to person. So, just get the one you can get now, since it's bas...
Thanks for the feedback to give me the nudge I needed.
I am the OP and it's interesting to read the good comments here. Thanks. I will confess that I orginally requested to have the Automatique because the dial is simpler and what I generally prefer. But as soon as I left the boutique, I couldn't get the Lune...
For me the Lune
I like moonphase complications. And the details of the moon on that piece are superb. The blue also adds a nice contrast to the dial. It will pair nicely with a blue strap. I have my name down for that piece but in Platinum.
Aaaah, a blue strap! Sounds like a good idea.
I know where to get one made, but I have to get the watch first! ha ha (tears, tears)
You can always get it on the blue FP strap.
If you are getting the watch from a boutique, they will put it on any color strap you want. They might even give you a second one at no extra cost.
Wow! Now I can see about getting even more than the watch, whenever that is, and one step at a time!!
Thanks, I didn't about the strap option. I will look into it when the "big day" arrives.
Yes, I agree and requested it.
I see why the Lune is a popular model. It really is a looker.
Hybrid
I really enjoy the moon phase complication. I don’t know why, but knowing where we are with respect to the moon phase feels relevant to me. I guess night time outdoor events like boating, camping, or just sitting around a fire pit are affected by the poss...