Lug length is always a major consideration in addition to case diameter...

Jan 26, 2020,04:47 AM
 

A 44mm FPJ Linesport has no lugs, so it may wear similar to a 40mm watch with lugs. My 6"/154mm wrist is a bit smaller than yours, so on traditional watches with lugs, I always go with a smaller (38-40mm) case diameter if I have the option. That's why I'd get the 40mm Optimum. But as others have said, you really do have to try it for yourself.

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Thoughts in Chronometer Optimum 40 vs 42 mm.

 
 By: Costa (aka Connie) : January 23rd, 2020-17:39
I have a 7 inch /17 cm wrist..I have the possibility of purchasing a 42 mm platinum version. I am wondering how it wears on the wrist?. Usually I like dress watches to be no more that 40mm. Thanks CB

If you like 40mm, get a 40mm CO.

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : January 23rd, 2020-18:00
I feel like the 42mm is for people who feel the 40 is too small. I have a 7.25" wrist and 40mm FPJs feel right. I can wear a 42mm and would if that's the size a watch I loved came in, but since there's a 40mm option, I would recommend that to someone who ... 

Thank you very much.

 
 By: Costa (aka Connie) : January 23rd, 2020-19:02
Good logic. Sounds perfect.

40mm

 
 By: DoesNotTickTock : January 23rd, 2020-18:33
I would go for 40mm personally. It seems to wear bigger.

40 [nt]

 
 By: cmmnsens : January 23rd, 2020-19:06

Thank you very much gentleman.

 
 By: Costa (aka Connie) : January 23rd, 2020-19:40
I’m trying to keep my emotions in check. I think 40 mm is the correct size but when a very nice 42 mm CO is possible it can be tough to maintain objectivity. I appreciate your help. CB

It’s personal

 
 By: ChristianDK : January 24th, 2020-07:21
I think, most importantly- try both and see what you think works best for you! Personally I prefer 40mm. But my sweet spot for watches generally, is 38-40 mm.

Agree with the others

 
 By: mac : January 24th, 2020-08:28
If 40mm is your sweet spot, don’t go for the 42mm. You will regret it. 40mm is also my comfort spot for most watches. I think the Optimum wears bigger than most Journes. It definitely wears bigger than the 40mm Centigraphe (my favorite FPJ) since the beze... 

From a Monochrome Review

 
 By: mac : January 24th, 2020-19:14
From a 2014 Monochrome review: “ The platinum case measures 40mm (note that the watch is also available in 42mm. The only thing that changes is the size of the bezel and of the lugs, both thicker. The dial remains the same diameter) and 10mm height.”

Thank you!

 
 By: Fastwong : January 25th, 2020-19:55
That's what I thought from the pics. I would prefer a 42mm but not if it's just a thicker case. I would vote for the 40mm

always good with a fresh view :-)

 
 By: ChristianDK : January 25th, 2020-14:58
Most important, is that it fits the wrist, I think..

Lug length is always a major consideration in addition to case diameter...

 
 By: CR : January 26th, 2020-04:47
A 44mm FPJ Linesport has no lugs, so it may wear similar to a 40mm watch with lugs. My 6"/154mm wrist is a bit smaller than yours, so on traditional watches with lugs, I always go with a smaller (38-40mm) case diameter if I have the option. That's why I'd... 

Thank you very much.

 
 By: Costa (aka Connie) : January 26th, 2020-19:47
I never really thought about lug diameter. I will consider it. Very informative. I appreciate it.