A. Lange & Söhne

If you already have this.... Are you going to buy this?? Pic credit to Patrickh....  

Why not, but I would maybe let the first one go... Best, Nicolas

The slimness of my wallet would, however.

I would let the first one you really like lumen why not try a zeitwerk lumen as well Best, Ahmed

At the end of the day, I would suggest to have one but not both. Fx

If I were to make a choice between the 2, my preference would be lumen moonphase. They are too similar IMHO that I wouldn\'t want to have both. Just my take FWIW Bests

Why not? They do both have a different feel to it.

A pair of watches that sings to you is better than going for diversity for the sake of it. I think you have enough of that, so why not make it a double if there's the inclination and the watch budget. It would make an impressive set! cheers fernando

Don't get me wrong, I'd rather have the two of them than 'only' one. But they are very similar in my opinion. So it's tough to advise. Let's say if your collection consist of 6+ watches and you got all brands, complications and metals(you like) covered, t... 

I prefer not only the composition of the dial... but particularly the color of the lume ( not green) as well as the size (smaller) and layout of the Romans on the moon example... also feel that the moon is relevant to a luminous watch, night time the moon... 

... and vote for the non-moon phase version. The dial is busy enough as it is. I also wouldn't keep both in my collection. They are just too similar.