WPS member · Independents forum
56 replies19178 views1 photos
The Greubel Forsey Balancier 3, a more accessible iteration from the independent horology powerhouse, sparked considerable debate among collectors. Original author m2's initial impressions highlight the watch's impressive wearability and distinctive curved crystal, yet raise questions about potential compromises in the brand's signature high-level finishing. This article delves into the community's diverse perspectives on whether the Balancier 3 successfully balances accessibility with Greubel Forsey's revered craftsmanship.
Their more affordable version of the Balancier. I had the chance to try a few of the Balancier models at an AD in CDMX recently and was really wowed by them in person. The curved crystals are very very cool and they wear nicely.
When I did a bit more research on WPS and some other places though, it seems like they've cut back on a lot of the super high level details that they are known for with this series.
Any thoughts?
Honestly if these end up settling low enough 2nd hand I think I might grab one anyways. I really love the curved crystal + how they wear.
Pic is from Monochrome
Key Points from the Discussion
- Despite concerns about reduced finishing quality, a visit to the Greubel Forsey manufacture confirmed that all individual parts, including screws, still receive the same extremely high standard of hand-finishing, with price reductions attributed to a less detailed case, a flat balance, and fewer total components.
- The Balancier 3, while sharing the same finishing quality as higher complications, offers superior comfort and legibility for daily wear, making it a preferred choice for many collectors despite owning more complex and limited-run pieces.
- The shift to a flat balance wheel, as opposed to the inclined balance, was likely a design choice to achieve a thinner profile for the watch, and some collectors do not view this as a detriment to the watch's appeal.
- The new management's direction, potentially with reduced involvement from Stephen Forsey, is seen by some as a departure from Greubel Forsey's earlier 'explosion of high-tech modernity, organic shapes, and contrasting details,' leading to a loss of the brand's unique dramatic experience.
- The use of '1 of XX' numbering plates on 'convexe' watches, rather than individual numbering, raises concerns among some collectors about potential undisclosed production volumes and a departure from traditional limited-edition practices.
- The proliferation of Balancier variations—including different bezels, materials, and sizes—coupled with a price point similar to earlier versions despite simplifications, leads some to question the strategic coherence and value proposition of the Balancier 3.
Advertisement
Continue the conversation
This thread is active on the Independents forum with 56 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.
Join the Discussion →
