Audemars Piguet Royal Oak 15202 vs 15300
Review

Audemars Piguet Royal Oak 15202 vs 15300

By ImranLondon · Jul 21, 2018 · 18 replies
ImranLondon
WPS member · Audemars Piguet forum
18 replies13935 views26 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

Miranda, a seasoned collector, ventures into the world of Audemars Piguet Royal Oak for the first time, offering a comparative review of the iconic 15202 'Jumbo' and the 15300. This article provides a fresh perspective on these highly sought-after references, detailing their design nuances, movements, and wearability. Readers gain valuable insights into the subtle yet significant differences between these two celebrated Royal Oak models.





In 28 years of watch collecting I have never owned a Royal Oak, infact until I got the chance to do this review, I had never even tried one on my wrist!

So perhaps its kind of bizarre that an Oak novice like me should ever dare to even try a review!!






Recently I thought I really must see what all the fuss is about, enticed by all the pictures posted in this forum I headed off to a dealer. There is a waiting list here in the UK so the only option was grey and paying a premium. Should I desire one....


The original classic from 1972

To my surprise the dealer pulled out two, one less expensive a reference 15300.

Both were 39mm and with the signature blue dial.

The reference 15202






This is the daddy!
True to the 1972 original and with the same calibre 2120 movement. It has a petit tapisserie dial and applied AP logo at 6 o’ clock like the original. It’s also very thin at about 8mm





The clasp is very good and quite solid in constructing 







The bracelet of course is pure magic, the detail of finishing is impeccable 









Reference 15300
This had been discontinue, superseded by the ref 15400, but this is 41mm.
In terms of proportions the 15300 is definitely the more original.

I had a degree of prejudice against this, simply because its not the original jumbo.





But here is the reality, think of the 15300 in the same way as the Patek Philippe 5711. Like the 5711, the 15300 has an in-house movement, quick set date, centre seconds and a screw down crown.

In many respects this is the better all round watch compared to its illustrious forbear.

It’s definitely more practical.
It has the in house calibre 3120 with 3.0Hz frequency, bidirectional 22k rotor and 11 3/4 lignes diameter. It boasts a 60hour power reserve.



The bracelet is impeccable again and has an elaborate clasp mechanism (comfortable but looks less sturdy)











The dial has a grande tapisserie finish



The thickness is more at 9.4mm



But on the wrist you don’t feel it. The watch feels more hefty and sturdy- more practical and confidence inspiring.

15202 v 15300

Overall it really depends on what you are looking for. The 15300 was £5k less expensive and if you can be happy with a black or white dial the 15300 is half the value of a jumbo.

Pro and cons, the finish on the AP logo was distinctly better on the 15202, a minor detail maybe 



The 15202 had a better clasp and of course the legendary movement- though the 3120 is a better movement except in emotional value 

The dial is also more luxurious in the 15202

In an ideal world I would have both, one for Work and one for special events - the 15300 exceeded all expectations, I was truly impressed and it carries all the DNA but in a modern package 

But if I had to have only one, of course it has to be the original.


Best
Imran




About the Audemars Piguet Ref. 15400

The Audemars Piguet Royal Oak reference 15400 represents a pivotal moment in the iconic collection s evolution, introduced in 2012 as the successor to the beloved 15300. This reference marked the transition to a larger 41mm case size while maintaining the essential design DNA established by Gérald Genta s revolutionary 1972 original. The 15400 served as the flagship time-only Royal Oak for nearly a decade, embodying the perfect balance between contemporary sizing preferences and the model s legendary octagonal architecture. Its significance lies in bridging the gap between vintage proportions and modern wrist presence, making it highly sought after by collectors who appreciate both heritage and wearability.

At the heart of the 15400 beats the manufacture Caliber 3120, a self-winding movement that showcases Audemars Piguet s horological mastery through its 22k gold rotor and 60-hour power reserve. This robust caliber features a frequency of 21,600 vibrations per hour and incorporates the brand s commitment to finishing excellence, visible through the sapphire caseback with its Geneva stripes, circular graining, and beveled edges. The movement s architecture reflects decades of refinement, delivering reliable timekeeping while maintaining the slim profile essential to the Royal Oak s elegant proportions.

The 15400 s design epitomizes the Royal Oak s distinctive aesthetic codes: the integrated steel bracelet with alternating brushed and polished surfaces, the iconic octagonal bezel secured by eight hexagonal screws, and the Grande Tapisserie decorated dial that creates mesmerizing light play. The silver dial variant particularly exemplifies the model s versatility, offering a refined backdrop for the applied hour markers and Royal Oak hands. From a collectibility standpoint, the 15400 has achieved significant recognition as the last generation of the 41mm time-only Royal Oak before the introduction of the current 15500, positioning it as a modern classic that captures both the model s evolutionary peak and its enduring appeal among discerning collectors.

Specifications

Caliber
Cal.3120
Case
steel
Diameter
41mm
Dial
silver
Water Resist.
50m
Crystal
Sapphire

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
GR
Greenwatch
Jul 21, 2018

I, for one, was also thinking of a 15300 as well. This review made me appreciate the said model more than before. Hopefully AP will bring back this model which is a better size for my wrist. Thanks for sharing!

SP
Speedie74 aka Mr. Torquise
Jul 21, 2018

I owned both and can also compare them, maybe in a little subjective way.. The 15300 was my very first AP, therefore my personal chain was very strong for that particular model! I think the 15300 is a true classical watch, I loved it, and some of the details are even better than the 15202: it has a quick-set date, an in-house, reliable movement, and it is more sporty, more tool-watch, as the 15202, due to its thicker case and wider bracelet at the clasp side. The 15202 is more fragile, more eleg

JT
JToddH
Jul 21, 2018

You seemed to capture a lot of details in your report. It’s good information as I am learning more about AP in hopes of adding one to the collection.

CA
cazalea
Jul 21, 2018

Hi Imran, I have almost as limited experience with Royal Oaks although I have owned and appreciated one for about 5 years. On the ones you reviewed you rightly took off the serial numbers - but is there also a model number on the caseback? How in the world would one know which is which without a serious course in AP appreciation? Perhaps the AP fans can point me to a summary or family tree of RO. I confess I bought mine on impulse, having gone to the store to buy earrings for my wife's birthday

M4
M4
Jul 21, 2018

I've owned both watches and wouldn't hesitate to own them again. Two comments based on my ownership: 15202 "Jumbo" is the most comfortable bracelet watch I've ever owned. It simply conforms to the wrist and wears light and inconspicuous. 15300 has the advantage of the center second hand which brings life to the dial, which I missed in the Jumbo. Again, I'd own either reference again. They're both excellent daily wearers. M4

BO
Boris
Jul 21, 2018

Those two models are easily the ones I prefer in all of AP's production. Shame that the 15300 is no longer produced, I find that the 15400 wears much too large at 41mm + integrated bracelet. But if I was to get one, it would be the 15202, for its sleekness. One of the rare watches on a bracelet that can be considered a dress watch.

Advertisement

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Audemars Piguet forum with 18 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →