RB1 or Montoya Ti?

I have recently sold my survivor and I am looking to buy a new watch. I now have the option of an RB1 (95% condition) and a Montoya Ti (100% condition), both are similarly priced with the Montoya $1000 USD more. I like both watches, the Montoya for the materials used and its durability, the RB1 as it was the watch that first started my interest in AP and the lower edition release. I am buying the watch to wear and although its not first priority, long term value/appreciation is a factor I would like to consider . At the moment its a very close decision and I would love to get other AP enthusiast's thoughts on which one they would choose and why?

Thanks all.

This message has been edited by DNWA on 2010-04-12 07:26:06

💰1482 Marketplace Listings for Audemars Piguet›

Personally I would go with the Montoya over RB I

By: ThomasM : April 12th, 2010-09:28

Hi, DNWA, Of course, personal considerations override everything else - a personal connection to RB; the RBI being the first watch that piqued your interest in AP; etc. But on the basis of the watch alone, the Montoya started the "evolution" of the ROOS t...

+1 to everything TM wrote

By: AnthonyTsai : April 12th, 2010-09:38

Definitely the Montoya over the RB1 for me. - AT

Same here

By: totalwatch : April 13th, 2010-14:47

Totally agree. I think the RB1 is not unique enough and I too prefer special editions to be well more.. Special! Though If it's the RBII then I think that over the Montoya.

thanks

By: DNWA : April 14th, 2010-06:05

Thanks all, much appreciated - Thomas / Anthony - Always enjoy reading your responses so special thanks for coming back so quickly. I will let you know how things go. Dan

My choice in the end.

By: DNWA : May 15th, 2010-11:10

Thanks for all your input. Ended up pending a little more and now have an RB2 TI instead - very happy! I will have to leave the Montoya and RB1 for another day. Dan

Congratulations! Hey, now about some pics to share with fellow AP addicted?

By: ThomasM : May 15th, 2010-12:36

the MONTOYA was also designed by RICHARD MILLE

By: Mohannad (aka Riddler) : April 12th, 2010-12:27

or at least involved in the design

It was not designed by RM...

By: ThomasM : April 12th, 2010-17:27

Hi, mabanomy1, I'm not sure how much of the idea came from RM, but I can tell you for sure that Octavio Garcia and his internal team did much/most of the conception and finalizing of the design. Octavio actually told me he read and followed the initial NE...

I remember comments.

By: MichaelC : April 15th, 2010-07:13

Outside of our community, the flaming was hot (sorry, couldn't resist that I guess!). "What is AP doing", "ugliest watch ever". It warrants its own thread to further explore the topic, and I will try and post something soon to get us going.

Not just outside our polite community, Micheal. In the original AP forum on ThePuristS

By: ThomasM : April 15th, 2010-10:38

I recall comments like "hit every branch on the ugly tree as it fell"

The Montoya was soooo ugly

By: AnthonyTsai : April 15th, 2010-18:39

that when I walked into my AD, they happened to have a rose gold Montoya in stock that day for some strange reason. I looked at it, tried it on my wrist, and then whipped out the plastic. That was the best impulse purchase I've ever made! I will always re...

Wow

By: totalwatch : April 16th, 2010-04:01

That was really lucky.. congrats and wear it in good health the montoya RG looks amazing and will always go up in value and along with the RBII RG.

montoya [nt]

By: Hororgasm : April 14th, 2010-12:41

No message body