The results and judges for 'Your Oldest Watch' Wristscan...

Feb 19, 2017,11:08 AM
 

Great Wristscan this week, with some really old and rare watches coming out to show.  Also some great stories and history of how they came to be in collections and loved pieces.


For the judges this week we have 2 regulars and one newbie, so please be gentle on him guys...



WristScan - ToddH (any old Heuer pics will certainly get double points!)

Static - Sascha (our new judge and newly found photowiz on the Hublot forum, just come and have a look a some of his great pics, especially his Frozen ones...)

WOW - Magnus (needs no introduction, again any Zenith pictures will score double points)

Thanks all for joining in and see you next week!
Andrew


  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Watch of the Week - Judge Magnus!

 
 By: andrewluff : February 19th, 2017-11:13
Thank you Magnus for judging this week and here are his results: That was a cruel exercise with all these wonderful specimens running for the crown. My Selection goes: First Place - ‘Alain2701’’s Minerva 13-20CH, for its sheer beauty and the excellent ena...  

I couldn't agree more with your first place choice!

 
 By: JToddH : February 19th, 2017-11:43
Alain's Minerva represents more than age, it's from a critical period when the market started shifting from traditional pocket watches to wristwatches as we know them. This piece perfectly captures that pivitol moment in history. The strap, the case, even... 

+1

 
 By: Alkiro1 : February 19th, 2017-14:13
Best wishes Alkiro

What a beautiful piece, congratulations Alain :) Thank you very much for the runner up place Magnus I am honored :) MTF, Nilo and Subexplorer amazing pieces as well friends and congrats :)

 
 By: Rogi : February 19th, 2017-15:17
To everyone who entered, thank you all for taking part as we truly have a passionate community and I love looking at all those amazing pics and being left stunned

That Minerva is just stunning!

 
 By: jporos : February 19th, 2017-16:09
Congrats to everyone for their vintage beauties!

Congrats to Judge Magnus and to winner Alain! Also congrats to special mentions, and ...

 
 By: Subexplorer : February 20th, 2017-04:14
... I appreciate receiving an special mention too! Have a great week friends! Cheers! Abel

Thanks a lot! :)

 
 By: alain2701 : February 21st, 2017-06:00
Thanks for judging ! A very nice watch indeed.. And its marvelous 13-20CH caliber ... ...  

Wristscan Results are....

 
 By: JToddH : February 19th, 2017-11:36
Rogi's Glashutte takes takes it this week. This survivor exudes the style and craftsmanship that draws us all to the art of watchmaking. I've no doubt, all the battle scars are honest and well earned. Regardless of your taste in watches, this one commands...  

Thank you Todd! [nt]

 
 By: andrewluff : February 19th, 2017-11:54

Well done, Rogi [nt]

 
 By: amanico : February 19th, 2017-12:06
No message body

Huge congrats Alkiro

 
 By: ch9698 : February 19th, 2017-15:49
Very happy for you

Thank you Todd, what an honor my friend, especially in a very tough week of judging I think we made it tough this week ! :)

 
 By: Rogi : February 19th, 2017-15:23
This piece falls into my love of history and it's fortunate we have the opportunity to mix tastes in the collection just love the history from this piece, I wish some of these pieces could talk and tell us their stories. Also big congrats to Alkiro, what ...  

Well-deserved, Rogi. [nt]

 
 By: TheMadDruid : February 20th, 2017-09:54

Great job Todd!! Congrats Rogi!! Great winner!! Congrats to...

 
 By: Subexplorer : February 20th, 2017-04:17
... my friend Alkiro for his special mention too! Have a great week! Abel

Many thanks my dear Abel and congrats to you too

 
 By: Alkiro1 : February 20th, 2017-09:25
Best wishes Alkiro

Thanks a lot my friend! Abel [nt]

 
 By: Subexplorer : February 20th, 2017-11:49

;-)

 
 By: Alkiro1 : February 20th, 2017-12:10
Best wishes Alkiro

Great results!

 
 By: Harry2 : February 19th, 2017-14:05
Certainly a fascinating wrist scan theme

Congrats to the winners

 
 By: Arie - Mr Orange : February 19th, 2017-15:59
And of course all the participants for all the shown diversity of watches and stories

Thank you Andrew for this great Wristcan...

 
 By: Mike H : February 19th, 2017-17:04
First of all congrats to all judges, winners, runners up, and participants. It has been a fantastic Wristcan because the theme was fantastic, thank you for that Andrew. I would have been delighted to participate as I was inspired by the theme but it took ... 

A special moderator's award to Mike H . . .

 
 By: Dr No : February 20th, 2017-10:27
. . . for effort above and beyond the call of duty. Thank you, Mike. This place is special because of folks like you who care enough to make the effort. A lesson for us all, in one way or another. Art ...  

Great shots Mike! Well done Art!! Fantastic shots and...

 
 By: Subexplorer : February 20th, 2017-11:50
... same for the watch with tha added great value of its provenance! All the best Mike! Cheers! Abel

Static - the results

 
 By: Sascha : February 21st, 2017-00:29
Dear Friends, to be a judge in a competition like this is an honor for me. But this decision was a tough one. So many different beautiful watches of all ages in very nice pictures...! But finally here´s my choice: My first price goes to: Alain 2701 and hi...  

Great work as Judge Sascha! And well deserved winners and special mentions!! Congrats...

 
 By: Subexplorer : February 21st, 2017-04:45
... to all you guys!! I also like to look with much interest the different markings left by watchmakers inside the back of watches after making a service or repair. They mark the history of the watch and give much intrigue and speculation and many thought... 

Great judging Sascha!

 
 By: andrewluff : February 21st, 2017-07:41
and thank you for spending the time to judge. It is not Sascha's fault by the way for the late decision but problems with our PM system! Cheers Andrew

Damn! I guess my bribery hint . . .

 
 By: Dr No : February 21st, 2017-15:34
. . . was too subtle.

How do you know those aren't Grants and Benjies . . .

 
 By: Dr No : February 22nd, 2017-11:25
. . . under Washington? Gotta be careful these days ;-) . . .

Congratulations to all the winners!

 
 By: TheMadDruid : February 21st, 2017-06:01
Many, many great photos.