Thanks for understanding. I was really taken in by the teases but the reality was underwhelming....

Jan 16, 2018,19:38 PM
 

Kinda like the Last Jedi, it promises much but under-delivered.8-)

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

SIHH 2018: A new line of watches: Jaeger Lecoultre Polaris: Automatic, Chronograph, Chronograph World Time, Polaris Date, and Polaris Memovox.

 
 By: amanico : January 15th, 2018-00:00
Before unveiling the 5 new Polaris from the 2018 collection, let me first summarize the journey of this iconic watch from Jaeger Lecoultre, as it will help us to better understand these new offers. Polaris and Jaeger Lecoultre. This is a long and old love...  

Thanks for understanding. I was really taken in by the teases but the reality was underwhelming....

 
 By: kesharoo : January 16th, 2018-19:38
Kinda like the Last Jedi, it promises much but under-delivered.8-)

He he... ;) [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 16th, 2018-23:02

Wow

 
 By: watchuk : January 15th, 2018-00:11
Super impressed have been looking for a sports WT for a while.... I guess here we are!

Francois B. Watch and learn.

 
 By: xxn : January 15th, 2018-00:19
JLC continues to innovate. Always pushing forward whilst acknowledging its past. Unlike yesterdays debaucles, where that other brand is just taking the piss by milking the same cow.

Lab 3???

 
 By: DSF : January 15th, 2018-17:39
Any new development or innovation are welcome. I can’t wait! David

Thank you so much for confirming Nicolas!

 
 By: DSF : January 16th, 2018-00:55
Really something to look foreword to = )David

Yes!!! [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 16th, 2018-05:22

Ummmm.... interesting

 
 By: DSF : January 15th, 2018-00:21
1st it was the deep sea alarm that inspired a whole new line of modern vintage looking dive watches. Now it’s the Polaris turn to inspire a whole new line of modern vintage looking dive watches. It will be interesting to see if the Polaris 2 will inspire ... 

I concur

 
 By: Gelato Monster : January 15th, 2018-00:22
The Polaris Worldtimer is the only one I am falling for.

Blue

 
 By: Gelato Monster : January 15th, 2018-01:36
In Fagliano is gorgeous . But why not white dial?

Agree

 
 By: Gelato Monster : January 16th, 2018-13:00
Perhaps Blue and Black is more subtle and fitting with the world time.

I think so, too. [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 16th, 2018-23:03

IMHO

 
 By: Gelato Monster : January 16th, 2018-04:56
Polaris Chrono WT is better than Geophysics UT

Can't wait for your choice. [nt]

 
 By: Gelato Monster : January 16th, 2018-13:01

Me too! ;) [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 16th, 2018-13:12

A nice choice. [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 15th, 2018-16:34

Happy JLC went back to basics, simple dial !

 
 By: mahesh : January 15th, 2018-00:35
the Polaris Automatic No-date is a BIG YES ! Blue has some ‘glitter-ness’ in pic, got to see in flesh but the Black dial is clearly a ‘go-to’ choice. i love the level of detail, the 2 different finishes on the hands & dial…just loving it ! though I’m not ... 

I love the entire line, finally JLC moved in the right track

 
 By: fherradon : January 15th, 2018-00:40
it's taken them some time to get back to the sport line but the wait has been worth it. it really made my day! looking forward to see these guys in the metal specially the World Timer (blue) and the 50th Anniversary. Thanks for the report Nico! Fernando

I have to say that the Polaris Automatic...

 
 By: KMII : January 15th, 2018-00:41
Sings most strongly to me. I like the fact that it is something new in the line-up and the design, together with the 41mm case definitely appeals. The Memovox is of course a winner but then that was to be expected. Not a single one in the 5 watch line-up,... 

I reserve my judgment for later with more photos. because here I only like the Polaris Polaris. By the way I do not understand the choice of the name Polaris to the chronograph which has not

 
 By: Tyo : January 15th, 2018-00:42
Nothing in common with a Polaris. The Polaris automatic without date is way too big IMHO. That’s a pity. 3 mm too big. The blue one could have been really a killer

Sapphire. [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 15th, 2018-23:46

Nicolas......

 
 By: Baron - Mr Red : January 15th, 2018-00:52
.....fantastic review. Truly an excellent review. I need some time to digest this......

+1 here [nt]

 
 By: Bounce781 : January 15th, 2018-07:04

Nico.... after giving some thoughts....

 
 By: Baron - Mr Red : January 16th, 2018-04:42
I think TYO expressed it very well. Nobody ever blames Rolex of Omega for taking an iconic model and giving a new spin on it. I think the original and also Tribute versions of the Polaris are stunning watches. I think the "core" Polaris is possibly one of... 

Many thanks! [nt]

 
 By: Emile : January 15th, 2018-00:55

My pleasure, Emile. [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 15th, 2018-16:41

Yukkk [nt]

 
 By: manilx : January 15th, 2018-01:01

He he... [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 15th, 2018-16:41

I know, Belmont doesn’t need me

 
 By: manilx : January 15th, 2018-22:34
And many others....

? [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 15th, 2018-22:40

my yukk was as much for the brand

 
 By: manilx : January 16th, 2018-01:15
as for the watched themselves. Told you in the past how they treated me.... Can't ever forget that.

I understand, now. [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 16th, 2018-02:15

I really like that fact the there are many options for the straps....

 
 By: DSF : January 15th, 2018-01:09
Bracelet, rubber and leather which make much more sense than the deep sea line that only comes with a leather strap for a dive watch. Well done JLC!

Price?

 
 By: Exiztence : January 15th, 2018-01:19
Are there prices available?

Nice

 
 By: VinnieD : January 15th, 2018-01:25
Thanks Nicolas, great overview of this new JLC offering Very ambitious to launch an entire new line, I really like it and they should find their audience for this sport chic line if the price is right Their prices are available on their webshop. Just a ti... 

Nico, a splendid review & superb pictorial !.. From the Quintet here, I‘d guess for the WT/Chrono/Blue despite its 44mm..

 
 By: hs111 : January 15th, 2018-01:26
.. other than that I‘ll have to see first in real, I suppose.. Maybe the 41mm automatic/black with a metal bracelet, maybe - and/or the simple, almost austere Piaris Date. Options enough, I would say JLC hit it quite well, diversity is the word, IMO.. Thx... 

Don't no either yet.. So I will wait until seeing them on Feb 19 in my Boutique here.. ;))

 
 By: hs111 : January 16th, 2018-02:29
.. while Prima Vista I was pretty much drawn toward the blue, meanwhile the more versatile, classical black is growing in me. - Finally I have already several blue watches, the most recent one the 2017 Blue Memovox.. So still some twisting & tweating of t... 

Thank you for a great write up Nicolas! Very detailed and with the history of the Polaris it was very helpful.

 
 By: reintitan : January 15th, 2018-01:40
Personally, I think the Polaris Memovox LE is my favorite of this new sport watch line, but I do have some constructive comments on it. I think they should have used a super compressor case like the Tribute or at least a screw-down caseback. Further, I th... 

Nice post!

 
 By: Fla25 : January 15th, 2018-01:46
First off, thank you for this very complete article, it was a pelasure to read! I was aware of the Polaris but did not know all these details, I have to say I have to get used to the grained part of the dial, but I always appreciate particular and feature... 

I hate to say this...

 
 By: jomni1 : January 15th, 2018-03:49
The renders look like Fossil watches. Hope they look better in the metal. I think only the original Polaris homage has the JLC charm. But I guess they’re reaching out and trying new stuff. Hope the price is right too.

Haha. [nt]

 
 By: jomni1 : January 16th, 2018-18:09

The closest version to the early Polaris

 
 By: MTF : January 15th, 2018-03:53
Nico, You asked for a choice. based on the original tribute to a submarine travelling under the polar ice cap. I would say JLC gave themselves a wide interpretation to include travel time, chronograph and alarm. All are associated with navigation underwat...  

edit wrong quote

 
 By: Tyo : January 15th, 2018-07:59

oops...was that USS Nautilus?

 
 By: MTF : January 15th, 2018-09:46
Senility.... MTF

Phew

 
 By: 41northpole : January 15th, 2018-04:10
I understand why JLC are doing this. Putting a lot of the compressor series into a more classical case design. For me looking at these (might be different in real life) I don't see the chronograph or WT working very well. I realise an awful lot of you don... 

Thanks for beautiful and informative post...

 
 By: FanFrancisco : January 15th, 2018-05:40
Thanks Nico. Feeling is mixed for me. But one point I fully agree with you is that, we can’t treat these watches as tribute to or reissue of the Polaris 1968, rather have to try them a new series of Polaris or even 2nd generation of Polaris I would say. S... 

Nicely done, JLC.

 
 By: zabreg1 Mr White : January 15th, 2018-06:20
My favorite being the 'real' Polaris, but I quite like the Automatic no-date, too.

Can’t wait. [nt]

 
 By: zabreg1 Mr White : January 16th, 2018-20:27

Love it.

 
 By: ripper444 : January 15th, 2018-06:58
I think the “base” 41mm black dial with brown strap is the one i will get. I was looking to sell my IWC pilot chrono and this is a perfect watch to replace it with! JLC is the best!!

Excellent history lesson, Nicholas.

 
 By: Bounce781 : January 15th, 2018-07:06
I like the new line. Need more time to “digest” all the new options

Hello Nicolas!! I was eagerly expecting your report about the new Polaris models from JLC! Congrats on your superb thorough introduction to this new line...

 
 By: Subexplorer : January 15th, 2018-07:14
... being announced today by our beloved brand. We thank you so much for explaining the differences between so many new models. I feel happy to know that JLC has decided to introduce this new line of watches, meaning we will have a new temptation from thi... 

Ahh! To hunt a vintage one should be marvelous... but not easy task! I never dared to risk my Tribute. May be if I have my watchmaker friend to check its waterproofness ...

 
 By: Subexplorer : January 16th, 2018-12:01
... it would give me some peace of mind. In any case, the new model is already haunting me! You know how greedy I am!! Lol! Un abrazo mi amigo!! Disfruta el SIHH!! Abel

Ok, yes I will do that! [nt]

 
 By: Subexplorer : January 17th, 2018-04:41

Nice read, thank you.

 
 By: Arie - Mr Orange : January 15th, 2018-07:27
To me these ‘new’ watches feel like old watches. If you get my drift... I’m not excited. But who knows, maybe in the metal things could change.

A nice change to me is the

 
 By: riverside / Henry : January 15th, 2018-07:41
newly designed bracelet. The existing one is too old fashioned (I mentioned this many times to JLC boutique personnel) and the new one is much more contemporary. Among these 5 models, the world timer and the memovox look attractive to me, partly because I... 

Am I wrong? Please tell me the block of lume next to the date window will be centered?

 
 By: cazalea : January 15th, 2018-08:06
The artwork shows it too high versus the date window, on the right image Cazalea ...  

I went to the bank to pick up My Polaris

 
 By: Tyo : January 15th, 2018-08:12
I needed something to compare, and my feelings are the same as earlier. I like the Polaris, the dial aesthetic is cool and the new indexes and hands talk to me. Do you have any sides pictures? Maybe a side by side one with your Polaris? In any case, thank... 

Nothing sexy here...

 
 By: watchme : January 15th, 2018-08:16
I'm sorry, JLC, but I don't see anything here that makes me scream, "I've gotta get me one of those!" I think JLC has played the "safe" card with these releases. Whereas the Compressors were bold, very sporty and gorgeous - and did include Polaris DNA in ... 

It is never a safe card when you take the risk to play with an icon, Dean. Now you could expect something more daring, I totally understand that. But something tells me that...

 
 By: amanico : January 16th, 2018-11:36
It is just the beginning of the adventure. I don't see Jaeger Lecoultre stopping the Polaris Family with these 5... Time will tell. All the best, my friend. Nicolas

Thanks nicolas for this thorough report!

 
 By: dms : January 15th, 2018-08:37
Initially, the "simple" Polaris (no date, no alarm) made me wonder ... a Polaris without alarm ??? Then, with the addition of the chrono, chrono world time and date, it is clear that JLC is releasing a new line of sport watches "inspired" by the Polaris r... 

Nice, simple, clean

 
 By: Brego : January 15th, 2018-10:01
I love the collection. Felt that JLC was missing something from their sport watches and these offerings deliver in spades. Particularly like the no date automatic and the World timer with blue dial.

Interesting development.

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : January 15th, 2018-10:28
A "new" Sports line. Long time we have been waiting for this to happen! Not very surprising "news". Will have to digest this new line... Thank you for the great report, my friend! Best Blomman

+1 Not very exciting or surprising...

 
 By: cory : January 15th, 2018-23:19
And we have been waiting patiently. I really hope JLC delivers something truly new soon.

Totally agree

 
 By: smatt99 : January 16th, 2018-03:34
First thanks for the post. The master compressor line blew me away when it came out, unfortunately the model I loved the most wore a little to thick for me. I was hoping for a little more aggressive of a sport line.

Sure. [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 17th, 2018-08:57

Thank you for the masterful writeup!

 
 By: brandon1 : January 15th, 2018-10:37
First, let me thank you for the wonderful and extremely thoughtful presentation of the new watches. The sequential and side-by-side organization really helped me understand the new watches, and I'm sure this must have been a time-consuming article to writ... 

The Polaris Automatic made me think about the Explorer, indeed. But the finishings are totally different, and the applied 12 makes the difference. There are worse comparisons.

 
 By: amanico : January 16th, 2018-12:01
Thanks for your kind words, Brandon. No doubt that we'll discuss them quite often this year. Best, Nicolas

Thanks for posting.

 
 By: VMM : January 15th, 2018-10:44
I would like to say that I like what i see, but I don't. Let's wait to se some live pics and see the watches in the flesh. Best. Vte

Grazie Nicolas, as always, superb post ....

 
 By: pr.petti : January 15th, 2018-11:50
.... for me the choice is t he Polaris Worldtimer, surely (but i have in my collection the Master Memovox)

Thank you for this wonderful combination of a history lesson and an introduction to a brand new line, Nico!

 
 By: YpJ : January 15th, 2018-12:17
I was happy to see that JLC decided to modernize their design aesthetic (especially with the new Memovox) rather than simply produce another tribute. Obviously a necessary move to spawn a whole new line of watches. From this new Polaris family, my attenti... 

yes, that Longines Diver is a great piece, but you can't really compare a JLC calibre with 2824.

 
 By: Velociphile - No longer in the building : January 15th, 2018-12:56
They really are far apart. In a similar but different way, I just got a LHD Pelagos on a whim, sick of waiting for a Seadweller (too slow out of the blocks). It gains 4s/w and is impressing me with its Ti build and bracelet tech, freesprung balance and si... 

Thanks for the great post Nicolas!

 
 By: agyzace : January 15th, 2018-12:51
I would like the Tribute version, but there is one killer negative point (which also stopped me from acquiring the Zenith PuristsPro watch): - the caseback cannot be secured with screws...this kills it for me and I do not get it at all. It has to be a scr... 

Very nice to read you, dear Nicolas :)

 
 By: agyzace : January 16th, 2018-12:30
Your reply makes me intrigued. I will patiently await what's in store. Bonne soirée and in case you drop by ZH or Basel, please let me know. Would love to meet up, Alex

Thanks! [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 16th, 2018-13:13

Excellent post!

 
 By: Milan1 : January 15th, 2018-13:15
Excellent post, as always. The watches really nice, I think this is a good road for JLC.

Merci, Milan. [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 16th, 2018-12:15

Thanks for that review! Compared to the Geophysic collection, at least the didn't write "Polaris" everywhere. Some would have screamed!

 
 By: eklektik : January 15th, 2018-13:55
There is some very nice design here. One question though: why no gyrolab? They could have standardised their movement with this component. Is it not beneficial? Thanks again for sharing these novelties. Best, É.

No no gyro lab balance wheel stays..

 
 By: proestak : January 17th, 2018-11:09
Any way my point is, that sports watch should have a more robust caliber 899 is a thin more delicate Yiannis.

I just thought...

 
 By: eklektik : January 17th, 2018-10:21
... that this balance wheel could be fitted in any movement. Is that not true? Best, É.

First thoughts: re Polaris Automatique no date et al

 
 By: remarque : January 15th, 2018-16:05
I don't understand this watch. Indices and arabics with super luminova, with super compressor type internal rotating bezel (not aligned in all published pics...) yet not a super compressor case, and no screw down caseback let alone screw down crown(s). Me... 

I totally understand your points. JLC is quite confident about the water resistance of the cases, here.

 
 By: amanico : January 16th, 2018-12:40
We want more, and we probably will get more... Later. The price points of the Automatic, Date and Chronographs are quite good, too. Best, Nicolas

I love JLC but too many options here..

 
 By: christianch : January 15th, 2018-16:10
confusing and all over the place.

Nice review, indeed! Thanks Nicolas

 
 By: gup502 : January 15th, 2018-18:40
I have always been a fan of JLC but I am sorry there is no 'WOW' factor, however these five versions should attract consumers maybe of a younger generation. When will JLC launch something entirely new? I have always been waiting...

I've never done this before...

 
 By: sternalot : January 15th, 2018-18:41
but I impulse purchased the 50th anniversary already...

Thanks for the great write up Nico!

 
 By: watchthatman : January 16th, 2018-02:26
I'm partial to the offerings that are closest to the original - the date and the memovox, but also find the world time is intriguing. As you mentioned, JLC played with Polaris DNA already in Master compressor, and reading this article actually made me thi... 

I find it strange that

 
 By: robsallnow : January 16th, 2018-09:45
all of the new range is visible on the JLC website, with prices except the Polaris Date.....I have to access that page via the link on the email I got from JLC. And then when you get to the page the price is 'On Demand'.....even the limited edition has th... 

Pleased to see...

 
 By: robsallnow : January 16th, 2018-10:53
they have now updated the website with the Polaris Date price but it's still hard to find the watch without clicking on one of the 'View Collection' buttons

Thanks a lot for this thorough presentation of the Polaris line!

 
 By: stromer : January 16th, 2018-12:29
From the pictures the models may not seem to be as daring as the Master Compressor line but they look well made and a solid sports line. I very much like the small red touches of the WT. Offering the base model with and without a date is a smart move. And... 

Great reportage indeed!

 
 By: massi. : January 16th, 2018-13:39
It's nice to finally see a wide range of proposals (you know how I'm tired to see a lot of brands change the color of the dials and sell this for wonderful news)! Kudos to JLC. I have a question about the chrono world timer: I see a "line", like a hand th... 

Am not sure, if I understood clearly.. Is it the line, looking like a hand (eg seconds) going from one day/night end to the one opposite..

 
 By: hs111 : January 17th, 2018-02:21
.. Somehow this bar is a bit confusing, but now I understand its function. - Nevertheless I would have thought they would be able to find another way for rotating the disc (?) I have appended a macro pic from website: on the black dialled WT it is dark gr...  

Wow amanico...

 
 By: jomni1 : January 16th, 2018-18:11
Looks like you responded to almost all comments!

I like them

 
 By: Horologically_minded : January 16th, 2018-21:36
But for some reason they remind me of some of the divers Oris had released in recent years.

At first glance I thought the numerals...

 
 By: Horologically_minded : January 17th, 2018-05:30
But on closer examination they are obviously different. Photo from watchtime. J ...  

JLC is becoming my favorite brand

 
 By: nafetS : January 23rd, 2018-05:46
I can understand, that some people might Not like these reinventions of old themes by JLC. I do like them . Until the geophysic 1958, i was interested in JLC, but there was no watch in their current collection, that I really wanted to buy. Since the intro...