First one for me! Probably the second

Apr 18, 2017,06:17 AM
 

one has color more accurate, but the first one has more character and the figure is better separate from the background, and you want that in this kind of portrait.

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Which one do you prefer?

 
 By: fernando : April 15th, 2017-22:05
1. 2. I'm trying to figure out whether a little processing makes a difference. Happy Easter! Fernando ...  

A bit more clarification....

 
 By: Andy : April 16th, 2017-07:01
The second pic looks more natural....especially her black top which in the first pic looks 'odd' and I find distracting. Andy.

Yes it does!

 
 By: JohnFM : April 15th, 2017-22:47
I'm not sure which one was post processed but I'm guessing it's the first one. The first looks more 'professional' -- more vibrant, punchy, and contrasty. The second one, though less exciting or attention grabbing, has a nice natural feel. My guess is tha... 

My thoughts as well and you aptly describe each convincingly.

 
 By: fernando : April 16th, 2017-05:27
Yes the first had some PP from a Jpeg shot. The second is pretty much SOOC which is normally good enough for me with my Fuji camera. However, I decided to tweak it further in LR to see if I could improve it. I made it more dramatic with finer details but ... 

First one for me. Warmer colours

 
 By: Alkiro1 : April 15th, 2017-22:49
Best wishes Alkiro

+1 [nt]

 
 By: Horologically_minded : April 15th, 2017-22:59

My pleasure

 
 By: Alkiro1 : April 15th, 2017-23:19
Best wishes Alkiro

True ;-)

 
 By: Alkiro1 : April 16th, 2017-09:27
Best wishes Alkiro

The first for me.

 
 By: aris d : April 15th, 2017-23:13
The lady stands out more from the rest. Aris

Clearly #1 for me...

 
 By: Mike H : April 15th, 2017-23:48
Crispier, colors more contrasted... There is much more life in it vs the 2nd one specially when you put the 2 pics side by side. Best, Mike

First one gets another vote :)

 
 By: SvB : April 16th, 2017-00:08
Although I like the color of her eyes in the second photo a tad more

first for me too

 
 By: andrew_sg : April 16th, 2017-00:26
I like the natural look, with the shadows in play..

Thanks Andrew! [nt]

 
 By: fernando : April 16th, 2017-05:35

I'm an amateur hobbyist...

 
 By: fernando : April 16th, 2017-18:49
who has developed a passion for photography these past couple of years and I do appreciate everyone's effort in helping me to improve. Thank you.

On my display...

 
 By: cshimokita : April 16th, 2017-01:02
For me the first image has more natural flesh tones. In person she may look more like number two (or not), but in the first one she seems to have a healthy glow. I also like the more vivid (by degrees) background... The 'down-side', if I could call it tha... 

+1

 
 By: Quan : April 16th, 2017-05:03
my guess she looks closer to #2

Spot on Quan! [nt]

 
 By: fernando : April 16th, 2017-05:53

You are right.

 
 By: fernando : April 16th, 2017-05:53
No. 2 is closer to her actual skin tone. The photo was taken with the 35/F2 Fuji lens with Classic chrome simulation ( not my favourite portrait lens though). I made the background in #1 more defined and vivid and assigned her a slightly healthier skin to... 

2nd photo

 
 By: W72 : April 16th, 2017-02:16
.. better colour balance. 1st is a little 'over cooked'? Just my eyes. /W72

I'm personally not in favour ...

 
 By: fernando : April 16th, 2017-06:02
of too much PP and it is becoming very prevalent in most of the professional portraiture that I see. However, they have to satisfy their client and this is what they want. I can understand your preference for No.2 but ''over cooked' might be too strong a ... 

First one for me! Probably the second

 
 By: julio3 : April 18th, 2017-06:17
one has color more accurate, but the first one has more character and the figure is better separate from the background, and you want that in this kind of portrait.

First one gets the popular vote!

 
 By: fernando : April 18th, 2017-16:41
Thanks for sharing your opinion.

Did you get permission...

 
 By: watercolors : April 18th, 2017-12:47
Fernando, my intuition tells me she would not be thrilled, but I may be wrong? Cheers Edward

No problem Edward.;) [nt]

 
 By: fernando : April 18th, 2017-16:42

#2 ..

 
 By: Echi : April 19th, 2017-01:10
Imvho shows off her natural beauty. Thanks for sharing! Echi

Good light btw :-) (nt)

 
 By: Echi : April 19th, 2017-04:00
..