Patek Philippe

I know this has been asked many, many times before, but I'm at the crossroads and am looking for last minute help. I just picked up a 5196J and love it and am looking for another everyday "sporty" Patek. My choice is between a 5711/1a and 5167a on rubber ... 

Gosh, at these prices, $4K does not seem like such a big deal when, as you say, you already know that you like the Nautilus more. The fact that you have owned both of these watches in the past puts you in the position of knowing for sure which one you pre... 

put the money issue aside and make your decision. I have both and prefer the Nautilus. For some reason, I just don't gravitate to the Aquanaut and defer to the Nautilus. Maybe it's the dial? I don't know how to explain it, I just feel more comfortable wit... 

I have a 5167 on a rubber strap and love it for its lightness - you really don't know you;re wearing it. I also have a 5712G, but I have a hankering for a 5711/1a too...If money is an issue you probably shouldn't be buying Pateks - there is no logical rea... 

works for me....  

what is the price spread if SS bracelet on 5167 vs the 5711? surely lesser then the 4k spread, so might as well go for the 5711, since you seems indifferent to both, prob a slight preference to 5711, which shld have made up your mind for you.

about a year ago when trying to decide which Patek to buy. I would not be worried terribly about €4k in such a decision & I love both watches. But without going into the minute details (which on the whole are expressions of personal choice), I h... 

that happened to me as well. So I got the 5167 first. Some time later as i think about it more, I found out that I also like the Nautilus. Then I got the 5980. If I were you, I will take 5167 and when you are ready, get a Nautilus. But if you have 5167, y... 

No message body

My problem is I like the 5711 just a tiny tad more than the Aquanaut. Just wondering if it's really worth spending an extra $4k for it. I think it's going to come down which watch looks better on my wrist vs. with is a better watch.

These questions don't make sense from someone who had both before, imo.