WatchProSite|Market|Digest

Patek Philippe

Isn't it a bit too baroque?

 
 By: amanico : December 22nd, 2013-14:07
Strangely, with the engraving on the case, these watches look a bit bling...

At least, in my opinion...

Best,
Nicolas

Engraving

 
 By: Le Monde Edmond : December 22nd, 2013-16:21
Thank you for this interesting post. It is relevant for a post that I am working on
regarding Patek and my family more specifically, what my mother created for her brother.
It is unique in this world, never been done before and everyone had told my mother it is IMPOSSIBLE
to do. Patek said no. All watch stores said no. The best craftsmen in the world told her no not possible.
I told her no- not possible. 

BUT she did it. She never gave up. The result is outstanding. Unique. 

And most importantly it tells a fantastic story between a brother and a sister.

Happy holidays.
Edmond

Edmond, with that kind of background info ...

 
 By: small-luxury-world : December 22nd, 2013-20:11
you have my full attention. I am really looking forward to your post.

Thanks and Merry Christmas!

Oliver

Baroque....

 
 By: Halcro : December 22nd, 2013-19:38
The amount of time taken for the engraving is no excuse for ugliness!
The Baroque period of architecture....which contributed some great structural advances via Borromini and Guarrini in Italy......led unfortunately to the Rococco.......championed in Bavaria and Germany which applied ornate decoration for its own sake.
In case you......or Patek hadn't realized it.......we went through the industrial revolution, the 20th century and now the 21st century.
The taste for this sort of mindless vulgarity (simply because it's possible).......is anathema for people of reason everywhere........

Amazing but.....

 
 By: Conkers : December 22nd, 2013-20:11
Amazing craftsmanship but it is just too much for me. I think that the 5160 just with the bezel done would be enough for me. Or the 5102 which if I recall just has the case sides done. Either of those perfect but the whole case is too much. I'd love to hear Khalid's take on this given his collection.  

"it is just too much for me"

 
 By: small-luxury-world : December 22nd, 2013-20:23
That´s fine smile

Thanks!

Oliver

Sorry

 
 By: Conkers : December 22nd, 2013-20:42
I wasn't intending to offend. They are exquisite but I prefer slightly less elaborate ie partial case engraving rather than full. Just my humble opinion of course. 

"Baroque ... mindless vulgarity ..."

 
 By: small-luxury-world : December 22nd, 2013-20:22
It´s clear you don´t like it, but this is no reason to offense to others and their taste.

Especially when it comes to classical music there are some great and outstanding examples from J.S. Bach, Handel, Scarlatti, Vivaldi ... which I like a lot. Well you could say we went through the era of Rock´n Roll ... still I love the Well-Tempered Clavier, the cantatas, the Mass in B minor ... and to be honest I am not interested in your opinion on that.

Some of the Baroque furniture is great as well, but underrated today ...

Maybe it´s because I am born in Bavaria ...

You are the Grand Master of Taste?! Hallelujah.

Oliver

to Halcro - "is anathema for people of reason everywhere"

 
 By: GLau : December 22nd, 2013-21:07

I totally agree with Oliver

just because you do not like this style, this is no reason to slam others who appreciate this type of rare craft

whatever you enjoy, there are others who think otherwise

this forum is about sharing and exchanging different opinions with respect


Funny, over here, Rokoko became popular because of Baroque's pomp ...

 
 By: Marcus Hanke : December 22nd, 2013-23:45
... that had become pure exaggeration: walls over and over plastered with fat angels, gold everywhere. Rokoko tried to lead the style back into the light mood, with more dynamic decoration, slimmer figures.

Anyway, while I like pocket watches with engraved cases, these wristwatches appear rather unpractical, regarding the attraction of dirt. Every cleaning procedure with a brush or something similar causes a loss of material, while ultrasonic cleaning makes it necessary to remove the movement. These are pure vault queens, and I thoroughly dislike the idea of watches being made to be stored away in a safe place.

What I do like, however, is the engraving of the movement.

Marcus

Beautiful art work, absolutely stunning for a piece of.......

 
 By: Sandgroper : December 23rd, 2013-03:35
jewellery but definitely not my cup of tea or camomilesmile for a Time-Piece. The mouvement though is pure Horological wonder to my eyes.
Thank you for the nice pictures.

Cheers

Francois from Down Under

Engraving on the case makes PP more special ..

 
 By: AbuLayan : December 24th, 2013-23:38

IMHO, Patek Philippe doing wonderful with the very awesome engraving on their timepieces cases ....

I was lucky enough to get the very beautiful 5101G  (white dial) with engraving on the case ..

I know, someguys gonna kill me coz of the sealing pack smile

 

Happy holidays all.

Simply ...

 
 By: small-luxury-world : December 30th, 2013-14:02
superb!

I hope you will find an appropriate occasion to put it on your wrist, one day.

Best,
Oliver

Amazing!

 
 By: Conkers : December 30th, 2013-18:03
Spectacular piece Khalid!