Comments:
I really dislike hobnails
.. hardly ever see them in the wild or on wristshot Fridays either. I'd avoid unless you're not considering wearing and just collecting.
And I love mine, so to each his own.
On the other hand, why do you suggest this for a collector? Unloved, so few made, so "value" added as a result? My question for this poster is what of the three watches you ask opinions on sparks your interest. Moreover, what is interesting to you should carry much more weight than what we think.