Comments:
Just for fun: 570G v 3417
And finally, one with a vintage twist. 3417....steel amagnetic versus 570G. Both quite classic watches in their own way but with very different personalities. Curious how opinions divide......
It is another example of....
.....horses for courses. In some situations, the 570 just kills, but in others the 3417 is King.
But...if push came.....3417 for me too.
But...if push came.....3417 for me too.
The amagnetic for me. Here, it's mainly because I prefer sub second dials rather than central second hands. In addition, the Arab index at 12 gives it more dynamism and modernity compared to the 570 (if we can really compare these both timepieces)
Nevertheless, I love the applied indexes of the 570 and the little dots all around the dial.
Best wishes
Alkiro
Best wishes
Alkiro
I don't have a preference for SC or sub-seconds....but your other points do resonate with me....the 12 is important....as is the Amagnetic writing [nt]
No message body
Both breathtaking, but here, I would go for the 3417. The perfect companion for the JLC Geophysic and the Omega Railmaster. [nt]
No message body
Both are beautiful!
If I had to choose one, it would be the 3417. Steel case, lugs and that dial! 
Here I can hardly decide...
Such a duel is cruel for both are really beautiful examples.
But since there is only one place on the podium, I vote for... the 570G.
As you say both have different personalities : maybe the 3417 is a bit more sport elegant, and the 570 is more classy classic so i would vote for the latter. Moreover I like not to be too conventional and it looks like everybody here choose the 3417 so I'll be glad to take the 570G and nobody will run after me (except maybe you Joe 
). LOL
Again congrats for both my friend.
Mike