Rolex Explorer 39mm: Reference Guide

Key Points from the Discussion

• The 39mm Rolex Explorer is characterized by its modern size and matte black dial, distinguishing it from other references.
• Key differences between the 39mm and newer 40mm Explorer include the matte versus gloss dial, the placement of the 'Explorer' text, the presence of the Rolex crown at 6 o'clock on the newer model, improved power reserve, and the addition of AR coating.
• The matte versus gloss dial is considered the most significant aesthetic difference, with the text and the tiny Rolex crown being minor details. The bracelet improvements on the newer models are noted, though the 39mm's bracelet was already highly regarded.
• The 39mm Explorer's hands were often criticized for being carried over unchanged from the prior 36mm model, leading some to view it as an 'oddball' reference.
• There is a concern that the new 40mm Explorer might adopt the 'muscular and bulky' aesthetic seen in recent Submariner models, moving away from the svelte design of older references.
• Some collectors feel vindicated by the return of a larger Explorer, appreciating both the 36mm and the 39/40mm sizes.