Rolex 5510 vs 6538 Big Crowns Comparison
Vintage

Rolex 5510 vs 6538 Big Crowns Comparison

By Bill · Dec 17, 2016 · 22 replies
Bill
WPS member · Rolex forum
22 replies11901 views5 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

Bill presents a rare side-by-side comparison of two iconic Rolex Big Crown Submariners: the Reference 5510 and the Reference 6538 4-line. His post offers a unique opportunity to observe the subtle yet significant differences between these highly sought-after vintage references, particularly focusing on case thickness and lug curvature.

22 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →
I hand the chance recently to photograph two great Rolex Big crowns the Rolex 5510 and the Rolex 6538 4 line. I must admit this 6538 is the best example I have ever seen and next to my 5510 you can see clearly the resemblance. 




Rolex 5510 vs Rolex 6538 - Rolex big crowns.


The 5510 was produced to replace the 6538 moving from the 1030 movement the 1530 bringing an end to the caliber 1030. While the Rolex 6538 was produced for several years the 5510 had a very short life with estimates of 400-600 units produced late 1958. The 5512 replaced the 5510 in 1959. The most remarkable difference, other than the movement as the share the same crystal, 8mm crown and bezel/insert, is the case. The case is much thicker to house the 1030 movement in addition the lug ends have a much more pronounced curve which is clearly visible side by side. This was the first time that i really noticed the shape of the curved lugs observing the two watches in an unpolished condition or at least as vlose to the original shape. 

No major revelations but i thought it was nice to share. 







Rolex 5510 top vs Rolex 6538 notice the curved shape of the lug tips.




Rolex 5510 top vs case thickness of the Rolex 6538 bottom.






Rolex 5510 and Rolex 6538 both with big logo bracelet. 

Enjoy

Bill   








Rolex Big crown 5510 and 6538


About the Rolex Submariner Ref. 5512

Rolex Submariner Reference 5512

The Submariner reference 5512 represents Rolex's no-date variant within the Submariner series. Distinguished by its clean dial layout without date complication, this reference was produced from 1962 to 1989, spanning nearly three decades of manufacturing.

The 40mm stainless steel case houses either caliber 1560 or 1570 automatic movements, providing 42-48 hours of power reserve. The watch features a black dial, unidirectional rotating bezel with aluminum insert, and acrylic crystal. Water resistance extends to 200 meters, with the watch fitted to a stainless steel bracelet.

This reference appeals to collectors seeking the fundamental Submariner aesthetic without date functionality. The extended production period and dual caliber usage create multiple variations within the 5512 designation. The no-date configuration offers symmetrical dial proportions that attract purists within the collecting community.

Specifications

Caliber
1560/1570
Case
Stainless steel
Diameter
40 mm
Dial
Black
Water Resist.
200m
Crystal
Acrylic

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
AM
amanico
Dec 17, 2016

I like these original inserts with the red triangle a lot. Thanks for sharing, Bill. Best, Nicolas

RO
rom
Dec 17, 2016

very interesting detail on the case differences !

BI
Bill
Dec 17, 2016

We really learn best by first hand observation. The more i see the more i discover. I know it is just minute details but i always find I like to share the small details. Thx Bill

SH
shipkeeper
Dec 17, 2016

Having 1 acceptable is difficult, but 4 spectacular is ...........?? All the best. Juan

BI
Bill
Dec 17, 2016

Four and you have a party. Hagwe. Bill

AN
Anatol
Dec 17, 2016

The big crowns are so mythical to me that they are the only Rolex watches I accept in less than fantastic condition. Now, seeing such perfect examples is really rare and hence all the more fascinating! I really enjoyed your pictures of those early heavy weights! Thanks, Bill!

Advertisement

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Rolex forum with 22 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →