Patek Philippe Nautilus 5711 Rotor Stuck

temps111 · 2014-08-06T22:26:07Z

Patek Philippe Nautilus 5711 rotor stuck? Explore warranty, service options, and collector advice on authorized vs. third-party repairs.

temps111

WPS member · Patek Philippe forum

28 replies13723 views3 photos

temps111 shares a critical issue with his Patek Philippe Nautilus 5711/1A: a stuck rotor. This post initiates a vital community discussion on warranty implications and the dilemma of choosing between authorized service and quicker independent repair for high-value timepieces. The thread offers valuable insights into Patek Philippe's service protocols and collector experiences.

28 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →

Hi all, I have been a passive reader of this site for quite some time now. Today I am reaching out to all of you because I recently encountered a problem with my Nautilus 5711/1A. I purchased this watch just a little under two years ago and wore it in extremely good health. Today I noticed that the rotor has completely stopped moving. The watch still runs perfectly but has to be wound every day, even if I don't take it off. Has anybody ever encountered a similar problem ?

I was told that the watch has to be sent to the Patek service center which could take around 2-6 months depending on whether the watch has to be sent to Geneva (probably not). My AD has offered to have one of his servicemen repair the watch. He informs me that this will only take 1-2 weeks but it will void the watch's 2 year warranty (which I have around 1.5 months left). Even though I trust my AD, the thought of having someone else service the watch makes me nervous. I was wondering if anybody has serviced their Pateks with a third party. Should I send it to Patek and wait it out or have my AD do it ? Your input is much appreciated.

Thanks.

About the Patek Philippe Complications Ref. 5711

The Patek Philippe Complications reference 5711/1A is a specific configuration within the Complications model line. This particular reference is identified by its serial number 5914840, with a movement number 6084863.

The watch is presented in a stainless steel case, indicated by the "/1A" suffix. No specific details regarding the crystal material or movement architecture are provided.

This reference appeals to collectors seeking a Patek Philippe Complications model in stainless steel. Its specific serial and movement numbers are documented for identification purposes.

Specifications

Caliber: 26-330 S C

Case: Stainless steel

Diameter: 40mm

Dial: Blue, White

Water Resist.: 120m

Crystal: Sapphire

Key Points from the Discussion

Aggressively shaking a high-precision watch with a stuck rotor, especially a heavy gold one, can exacerbate internal damage. The initial issue of a shifted dial jamming the rotor might have been repairable, but shaking could lead to irreparable damage.
Sending the watch to Patek Philippe's regional service center is recommended, as they are best equipped to diagnose and repair complex issues, ensuring comprehensive service including polishing, oiling, and gasket changes, which an AD watchmaker might overlook.
Patek Philippe can detect if a watch has been opened by an unauthorized technician, which can void the warranty and potentially impact future service or resale value. Unauthorized repairs can also lead to issues like rust or 'love marks' on the movement.
Wearing a self-winding watch, particularly one with a Caliber 324 movement, while playing golf can cause damage to the rotor due to the repetitive, forceful motion.
The original problem was a shifted dial that jammed the rotor, necessitating its replacement. The watch was returned in 'as good as new' condition after Patek Philippe's service.
Prioritizing Patek Philippe's official service, even if it means a longer wait, is crucial for maintaining the watch's integrity and warranty, especially for a high-value piece like the Nautilus.

The Discussion

amanico

Aug 6, 2014

Why not, if his watchmaker is good? After all, your watch will soon be out of warranty.

But, on another side, it is Patek problem and it is up to them to solve that. I will let Patek take care of that. Even if it takes more time. Best, Nicolas

Highlander65

Aug 7, 2014

As my friend Nicolas said let Patek take care of it and win the time out...Cheers, [nt]

Mark in Paris

Aug 7, 2014

You never know what will be found inside

Thus, I would accept waiting a bit longer but being sure that the watch is well repared (even though I don't know if the problem will be taken under warranty or if they could say it's been damaged for other reasons...).

COUNT DE MONET

Aug 7, 2014

Patek should do the repair. No reason to think about any other option. (nt) [nt]

Conkers

Aug 7, 2014

Agree.....

......plus you will get a further 12 month Patek warranty if they do the repair.........

ch9698

Aug 7, 2014

Would you give your Bentley to your local garage?

If yes, go to your AD if no...