Comparison
Dje's contemplation of the Patek Philippe Nautilus 5711/1A versus the Audemars Piguet Royal Oak Jumbo 15202 delves into a classic debate among luxury watch collectors. This post, rich with personal reflection and community input, offers a timeless comparison of two iconic Gérald Genta designs, providing valuable insights for anyone facing this pivotal decision.
Hi,
This is an old
story repeating. But I'm convinced that the same facts, brought over and
over, don't always bring the same outcome. In fact I've asked
myself that same question many times, but there's at least one aspect of
the equation that changes, myself!
As you
certainly know or noticed I've been lurking around the 5711 for a while
now. A long while in fact, a too long while. That's the most tempting new
Patek Philippe for me, because I love it, because I would actually wear it and
because that would be the most affordable.
To be honest
I'm getting tired to run after a mirage and I'm really giving up.
I'm
giving up and a new watch launched earlier this year is giving me the strength
to move my mind. The watch was designed by the same great man and has a close
positioning.
Each time
I've seen or tried an Audemars Piguet Royal Oak Jumbo, any version,
I've been appealed. The watch may be rougher than the Nautilus, or to be
clearer not show the same refinement, it has a strong design too. The 2121
calibre is a plus too, as it is a dream engine.
Audemars Piguet
launched a revised version of the modern Royal Oak Jumbo 15202 this year and
the new version seems to be in the best configuration a Jumbo could adopt. I
tried it at the SIHH and was really seduced by the move. My pics are very bad
but you can see it below on Foversta's picture.
Of course it is
not so more accessible new than the Patek Philippe Nautilus, but second hand
Jumbo models are in my reach in the precedent version (shown below in the form
of the upscaled dream PuristS 10th limited edition). I could choose
to take it as it is and live. It may be less beautiful than a 5711 but it may
be mine!
The point of my
question is to ask you if you think that I'm objective enough to choose a
sound solution, or if as a Patek Philippe forum moderator I'm
unconsciously sold to Patek Philippe and unable to make a sound choice?
I know that I love
the Nautilus 5711 but I really appreciate the Royal Oak Jumbo too and I may be
focussed on the Patek Philippe because I spend so much time here.
Maybe I should
take a 6 month rest reading on the Audemars Piguet forum and stop coming here for
that time?
But who can say
no to that beauty ?
Best
Dje
The Patek Philippe Complications reference 5711/1A is a specific configuration within the Complications model line. This particular reference is identified by its serial number 5914840, with a movement number 6084863.
The watch is presented in a stainless steel case, indicated by the "/1A" suffix. No specific details regarding the crystal material or movement architecture are provided.
This reference appeals to collectors seeking a Patek Philippe Complications model in stainless steel. Its specific serial and movement numbers are documented for identification purposes.
Can clearly compete with the Nautilus, being 3700 or 5711. I will go further... I find a R.O jumbo more appealing than a Nautilus, even a Ref 3700. I find the R.O more sport chic, less ... how to say it correctly... Mannered? The R.O is unique, in its look, and has been sometimes badly imitated ( Cf Hublol ) while the Naughty Lus is typically born in the Seventies, and this very special shape has been chosen for several TV screen watches, the PP being more sophisticated than the other TV screens
Hi my friend, Your argumentation is quite convincing and I agree with most of your points. Specially the last one. I f you can't do what you want, is it worth doing something for the sake of doing? Not so sure. I'll take a rest for this time. But I don't want to run after the Nautilus, not anymore. Best Dje
If it is a devastating love, or not. Best, Nicolas
nt
nt This message has been edited by Dje on 2012-05-01 14:17:29 This message has been edited by Dje on 2012-05-01 14:17:49
This thread is active on the Patek Philippe forum with 114 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.
Join the Discussion →
