Patek Philippe Forum Rules and Etiquette Guide
Community

Patek Philippe Forum Rules and Etiquette Guide

By ImranLondon · Oct 30, 2018 · 30 replies
ImranLondon
WPS member · Patek Philippe forum
30 replies11071 views3 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 ✉ 🔗

Miranda's post outlines the stringent rules and etiquette for the Patek Philippe forum, emphasizing a commitment to quality, evidence-based discussion over mere opinion. This foundational post serves to maintain a respectful and informative environment, setting clear expectations for contributors. It highlights the moderator's dedication to fostering substantive engagement within the community.

Here are the rules:

1. Break the rules you get banned- no warning ⚠️ 
I want quality of discussion not quantity 

E.g.



A blanket statement, no fact or evidence or statistics 

I gave the OP a chance:

www.watchprosite.com

I produce facts, still waiting to hear a response.... gone quiet 🤫 

Statement without fact=instant ban

2. Discussion can be had and opinions given when provided with a review 

Eg if you compare a AP Royal Oak Jumbo v Patek 5711 with good pictures, statistics etc and come to a conclusion that the Royal Oak is a better watch, then that's a valid point of view

Just making a statement like : the Nautilus is crap the Royal Oak is better finished : with no evidence=Instant ban

3. You don’t have to like Patek Philippe. You don’t have to spend your hard earned money on one. You can detest them infact: but you don’t disrespect the brand and its collectors here: instant ban if you do

4. As per 3: but applies to all other brands- don’t come here and say PP are great but AP or ALS or anyone including Timex are crap

5. Watch reviews comparing  watches with pictures, facts etc most definitely welcome

6. Comparing different Patek’s of all era welcome: if you think a cal 12’120” is better than a cal 215 and wish to show off your lovely piece, please do

7. Respect for others: not negotiable- any disrespect=instant ban  

So statement like this:






Without back up evidence=ban

Btw: Patek facilities at Fluckiger make the dials for other manufacturers too....

Please demonstrate the unorganised mess or guess what- BAN

Have a great 👍🏻 day
Imran

About the Patek Philippe Nautilus Ref. 5711

The Patek Philippe reference 5711/1A-011, part of the Complications collection, is distinguished by its white dial, offering a different aesthetic compared to other dial variations within the 5711 series. This particular configuration provides a clean and legible presentation, appealing to collectors who prefer a more understated yet refined look. It represents a specific iteration of a well-known Patek Philippe model, recognized for its integrated design.

The watch features a 40mm stainless steel case, housing the self-winding Caliber 26-330 SC movement. This movement provides a power reserve of 45 hours. The case is fitted with a sapphire crystal, contributing to its water resistance of 120 meters. The fixed bezel and integrated bracelet are characteristic elements of its construction.

This reference appeals to collectors interested in the evolution of Patek Philippe's offerings, particularly those seeking specific dial colors within established model lines. Its production run from 2019 to 2021 marks it as a relatively recent, yet now discontinued, variant. The watch's specifications align with Patek Philippe's standards for mechanical timepieces.

Specifications

Caliber
Cal.26-330 SC
Case
Stainless Steel
Diameter
40mm
Dial
White
Water Resist.
120m
Crystal
Sapphire

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
SP
Spangles - Dr. Tabby
Oct 30, 2018

Hi Imran, I appreciate your deeply felt posts about Patek and your desire for quality discourse about PP. Certainly, having challenging (yet civil) conversations is stimulating and it can be good to challenge quick opinions. But, please don't be so quick to ban people! Just to help save purists from a ban, I will defend mohammad's post, not really the tone, but the idea, if considered objectively. We have had a number of great and very helpful purists such as Patrick_y and yourself post pictures

IM
ImranLondon
Oct 30, 2018

Had it been a reasoned response with evidence and civil: no problem A statement that says Such bad finishing- quantify it Or quoting high price: when the Patek is cheaper That’s the problem Ive put up with it for too long. So extreme measures needed Opinion without fact is just worthless Would you accept your Dr opinion if it wasn’t evidence based? A few months ago, somehow a Brexit conversation went haywire A guy actually said this “You muslims all need to get out of our country, you’re all sym

DE
dedestexhes
Oct 30, 2018

it is always sad to have to announce such measures. It is so amazing how negative people can be. I never understood why people react on post in a negative way. I think it is often better to not comment, why wanting to hurt people or brands. I think the majority of our community, at least all the people I met, are people that respect each other’s opinions. And I think it all starts with respect. Now clearly it is sometimes a thin line as I’m also a huge supporter of freedom of speech and freedom

DM
Dmitriy
Oct 31, 2018

Initial. You ask facts. However, the facts cannot always be documented. If you have visited watch factories, you know that only a few are open as (Piaget, Omega, Ulysse Nardin) and allow you to photograph the process of making watches. For example (AP, VC, Glashutte Original, IWC, JLC, Blancpain, Breitling, Cartier, Nivarox...) "closed" and do not allow to photograph the manufacturing process. Therefore, in a dispute present the facts of AP is impossible. Second. Not everyone can have informatio

IM
ImranLondon
Oct 31, 2018

first as a keen historian I need to make you a humble apology Stalin was not an appropriate avatar to put up, the point I was trying to make although valid didn’t reference to Stalin So I sincerely apologise The Iron Lady makes for a better avatar....she did it her way too..... tough cookie even though I wasn’t a fan of her politics Regards Alex25, I gave enough opportunity, the statement he made were crass, without evidence and rude. His PM to me was equally derogatory My real day job involves

BA
Baron - Mr Red
Oct 31, 2018

Without any doubt, the Patek Philippe forum is the most difficult to Moderate. I do not envy Miranda his responsibility to keep this forum civil and positive. Over the last 10 years on this forum, I have seen a lot of things on this forum. Patek Philippe is loved and hated. Usually, the haters are people who have never owned a Patek Philippe and who have never visited the manufacturer or really even gone to much trouble to learn about Patek Philippe. The Patek Philippe forum can, very quickly, b

Advertisement

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Patek Philippe forum with 30 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →