Patek Philippe 5146G Annual Calendar Advice
Discussion

Patek Philippe 5146G Annual Calendar Advice

By Pun · Nov 18, 2019 · 32 replies
Pun
WPS member · Patek Philippe forum
32 replies7669 views4 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

Pun seeks advice from the WatchProSite community regarding the Patek Philippe 5146G, specifically inquiring about the annual calendar's adjustability and the preference between deployant buckle shapes. His questions delve into practical ownership aspects for a collector considering this significant addition.

32 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →
I’ve good collection of 24 watches that I’ll post sometime later for your perusal, my present query is about adding 5146G to join my Patek 5116r.
Please share your opinion on the annual calendar feature. Is it easy to adjust if I wear it once a while or it’s difficult and must be kept on watch winder if not worn regularly.
My another question is regarding its deployant buckle shape; I’ve seen both, a regular one and one with Calatrava cross shape. Which one will you prefer if given a choice.





























About the Montblanc Calatrava Ref. 5116

The Montblanc 5116 is a notable reference within the Calatrava line, recognized for its adherence to the collection's foundational design principles. This particular model emphasizes a clean, time-only display, appealing to collectors who value understated horology and traditional aesthetics. It stands as an example of the brand's commitment to classic dress watch proportions and finishes, distinguishing it from more complicated or sport-oriented offerings. The reference is often considered for its balanced presentation and its place within the broader lineage of the Calatrava series.

This reference features a case crafted from 18k yellow gold, consistent with the traditional material choices for dress watches of its era. The case diameter measures 33mm, a size that aligns with historical preferences for formal wristwear and offers a comfortable fit. It is typically fitted with a sapphire crystal, providing clarity and scratch resistance. The movement is a manual wind caliber, reflecting a classic approach to watchmaking and contributing to the watch's slender profile.

For collectors, the 5116 appeals to those seeking a traditional dress watch without additional complications. Its yellow gold case and hobnail bezel are specific characteristics that resonate with enthusiasts of classic design. The absence of a date window further enhances its symmetrical dial. This reference is often sought after by individuals who appreciate a more compact case size and a direct connection to the historical design language of the Calatrava collection, offering a distinct alternative to larger or more contemporary interpretations.

Specifications

Caliber
Cal. 215
Case
18k yellow gold
Diameter
33mm
Dial
White
Water Resist.
25m
Crystal
Sapphire

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
RA
Rapwatch
Nov 18, 2019
FWIW my advice

Don't keep on a winder. It's like running the engine in the garage. Easy to set so why 'winder' it. I prefer elegant buckle - lower profile, more elegant.

PU
Pun
Nov 18, 2019
I agree in toto

I totally am with you sir. I have not bought a winder due to that but till now I have only simple date or day date automatics. This would be my first annual calendar complication therefore I was in doubt. Now I’m clear and won’t use a winder. Regards

PA
Patekphilippecollector
Dec 19, 2019
If wonders are so bad why do PP provide them

With their grand complications?

W2
w220
Nov 18, 2019
I have heard that the reason the buckle style was discontinued is because it was somehow less secure. [nt]

PU
Pun
Nov 18, 2019
So the double Calatrava buckle is advisable then. [nt]

GL
GLau
Nov 18, 2019
Yes, easy to adjust once your learn the simple basic rules !

This is a very functional watch.

Available on the marketplace

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Patek Philippe forum with 32 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →