Thanks, George for your response. The MOP dial is indeed

Dec 29, 2007,09:49 AM
 

thrilling.


You know this type of question "This or That" is maybe a little inane. If it means "Which
watch should I buy" that is obviously a matter of the questioner's taste. If it's meant to solicit
a poll of others' tastes, O.K. If it's meant to ask for ask for an "objective" comparison of which
watch is "better", then "better" is difficult to quantify.


I chanced to see all three watches the other day, liked them all and was struck with some
similarities. They are all close to the same diameter (38.5 for the Langes, 39.5 for the Chopard)
and height. They all have in house movements and interesting technical features. They are all
beautifully finished, both dial and movement. They all have similar functions. And they each have
a little something extra the others don't.


So, all are three handed watches with date and power reserve. In addition the Lange 1 MP
has the beautiful and "accurate" continually changing moon phase. The L1 lacks the moon
phase but has the gorgeous guilloche MOP dial. The MP on one and the dial on the other give
each a warmth that Langes don't usually have (without sacrificing a certain crispness).


The Chopard has the "extra" of the eight day power reserve (and GMT function) and
also maintains an inviting beautiful appearance (its exuberance tamed by the black,white
and silver look).


The price on all three was roughly comparable. I own a Lange but not a Chopard.
Hence my dilemma.


More posts: Lange 1

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

This or That? Opinions solicited.

 
 By: hal : December 28th, 2007-14:49
Chopard Regulator WG (original model) or Lange Moonphase PG (silver dial) or Lange 1 Soiree WG (MOP dial). Please help me narrow this down.

Impossible because >>>>

 
 By: MTF : December 28th, 2007-19:47

Functions and differences aside....

 
 By: GH1 : December 29th, 2007-08:13
just taking you up on your 3 choices literally .....I will pick the Lange 1 soiree wg . The MOP dial is wonderfully detailed and that beats the moonphase imo. The chopard is nice too but just have a touch too many things going on on the dial and loses out... 

Would like to ask you a question another way round :-)

 
 By: Kong : December 29th, 2007-19:45
Your short-listed are 2 ALS & 1 L.U.C. Besides similar price range, what draws you to L.U.C Quattro Régulateur ? Kong PS : For me, a couple of points which are attractive : 1) heritage.... check out the origin of Régulateur...during ancient time as THE Re...  

Hi Kong. I have always admired the Chopard LUC series

 
 By: hal : December 30th, 2007-10:20
of watches ever since the original 1860 was released. The idea of original high quality movements together with a traditional commitment to fine finish and quality was very attractive. I was also drawn to the classical look of the early watches. Now,of co... 

Hal, you've already done your homework well...

 
 By: Kong : December 30th, 2007-20:14
Indeed Chopard L.U.C still adheres to its core values though moving some of its aesthetic to more contemporary. For the WG witih white dial, the variations are the one you've seen (black hour & minute rings) and the picture I showed (which could be still ...