you've got looks & charm vs personality & character. Back in the 50s, JLC was making most of the movements for VC. The dial and case may be what you look at first, and if it draws you, then consider the character before proposing. Personally, I like the JLC MUT QP. But I also like the white gold JLC MUT Master Calendar, which debuted 2 years ago, and that would be a closer comparison.
In the end, choose the one that speaks to your heart the most.
-Dean