....I think the hands and hour markers blend in too much with the color of the dial which could make telling time somewhat difficult -- this would especially be true if you are in a dark environment (I don't think the markers are lumin) -- but that may just be the way the photo was taken. I like the the bi-retrograde features -- these mechanisms are fun to watch (excuse the pun) in my opinion. I don't think you can go wrong with a VC, but as another commenter noted ("vitalsigns" I think), you sound like you have doubts. My position is if you feel you have doubts about a particular watch (it doesn't matter if it's a $150 or $15,000 piece), if you hesitate about it and need to get input from others, I would say go with your initial gut feeling and pass on this one. I have not done a lot of research on this particular piece, so unless it a very limited edition or bears some other notable provenance or for some reason has sentimental value to you, and the price is right, then I think you, as a watch enthusiast, should add it as part of your collection - you can never have too many VC's. If you plan on wearing this piece on a regular basis, only you can decide if the timepiece is for you. As I said, I don't think you can go wrong with a VC, but it's YOU who has to live with it. From the photo, it looks a little large on your wrist -- not necessarily a bad thing -- I have very thin wrists, but I generally buy pieces that are on the larger size because (a) I have somewhat poor vision so larger watches are easier for me to read (b) I like the feel of something substantial on my wrist (c) it catches the eye and other watch enthusiasts will definitely notice it. These are all very subjective issues. All of that aside, I love VC as a brand and would personally seriously consider the purchase if it were offered to me (especially on the generous sales terms that your friend is offering you). I would also find out more about why your friend does not like it after purchase -- will you have the same "buyer's remorse?" The reasons your friend may not like it may be reasons why you DO like it. "Vitalsigns" also mentioned another important consideration -- undeniable passion is key. I collect watches that I would enjoy and love looking at throughout the day -- if there's no passion in what I see on my wrist, then why did I buy it? Good luck on your decision making!