I'm an outlier here, but if I could have the 5127 without a date, it would be an easy decision to prefer the 5127 over the 5196P.
May 03, 2023,16:29 PM
I don't think the 5196s are particularly great on the wrist...an overall flat piece without many contours. One definitely buys the 5196P for its dial. That said, it is a lovely piece, but priced very dearly nowadays.
The 5127 exudes sensuality. Not a sharp edge to be found on the curvaceous case. Perhaps the original Galet if you understand the reference. A generation when the name "Patek Philippe" was very subtly printed on the dial. Perhaps only the wearer could rea...
While I very much welcome the new generation of models that is slowly finding its way into the Calatrava collection, I am sure that a more classical offering will never cease to play a critical role within Patek's lineup ;-) I'm happy to see the love mode...
I don't think the 5196s are particularly great on the wrist...an overall flat piece without many contours. One definitely buys the 5196P for its dial. That said, it is a lovely piece, but priced very dearly nowadays.
Someone once said: the best watch purchases are the ones that hurt a bit (financially). It's not a universal rule, but the point is strong. True desire, and perhaps long term enjoyment, is often manifested by ones willingness to endure a bit of pain.
My beloved 5110 has a very similar case but I think the lugs are slightly different, a bit more elongated on the 5110, and a bit more harmonious on the 5127.
Looking at them next to each other it seems clear that the 5110 bezel is a little wider (and taller?) than the 5127 bezel. Am I right about the difference between the lugs, or are they actually just the same?