You already have too many nice watches. :))) Yes, these are fantastic watches. I rediscovered the E 855 Black, I must confess. [nt]

Nov 21, 2017,12:24 PM
 

No message body

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Jaeger Lecoultre Memovox E 855 Black and E 859 Polaris 1965. A side by side picture, and a question.

 
 By: amanico : November 21st, 2017-00:38
The reason behind this side by side picture is not only motivated by the pleasure to see these 2 beauties, but to see how similar and different they can be, and to try to find an answer to the following question: Did Jaeger Lecoultre use the dial of the P...  

It's great to see them side-by-side and

 
 By: crown comfort : November 21st, 2017-02:10
yes, the dials have a lot in common. They do serve a very different purpose and will have a different wirst feel, but they are unmistakenly Memovoxes. The LeCoultre Polaris is my favourite. What a watch! CC

Great comparison shots JLC Memovox 1967 vs Polaris 1965

 
 By: Bill : November 21st, 2017-08:00
Hard to deny that they are very close but still look very different. Great pictures. Bill

I do not know all the tech in's and out's on these two but what I know: my wrist would be glad to grant them some space.

 
 By: HSTE : November 21st, 2017-11:57
Top notch pictures of to fantastic watches my friend! Cheers, HSTE

Hmm, there is a robust "family resemblance" with these two

 
 By: Tim_M : November 21st, 2017-18:45
But I believe that it is the product of coincidence or a series by a single commissioned designer. Since even the most complete manufactures rarely employed full-time designers until the 1990s, I suspect that JLC may have found a Vallee de Joux artist tha... 

Magali's signature was 'form over function'

 
 By: Clavi : November 22nd, 2017-02:49
It is sad IMHO that the only JLC 'designer' that will be remembered is MM. Likely because she was a young blond person and was quite exposed in the communication as such (yes, I said it, and if you look at the comments from admirers back in the days, comm... 

Freelance watch designers were very common back then

 
 By: Tim_M : November 22nd, 2017-04:04
This is exactly how most watches were designed during the mid-century period. Genta, Albert, Richard Arbib, and others worked almost exclusively on a project basis. And while JLC did not "style" the Ervin Piquerez-engineered Super Compressor case itself, ... 

Cricket nautical and Polaris 1965 aren't really different, and the Vulcain certainly sets the precedent

 
 By: Clavi : November 22nd, 2017-06:53
I would even argue that Vulcain Cricket Nautical is much more innovative, in that it incorporates a design for decompression times - so, a purposed design for divers - while the 1965 polaris is pretty much just a regular memovox 855 housed in the Piquerez... 

Awesome Collection

 
 By: Gelato Monster : November 21st, 2017-19:01
Thank you Nico. I always learn something from your post.

Both great watches & indeed some common DNA..You reminded me on my own E855 &..

 
 By: hs111 : November 21st, 2017-22:27
.. the way and circumstances it came into my house - very special memories & ocassion in a loved city, when a now very good friend so kindly consulted me @ a certain Horology store & watchmaker.. With that E855 my Purist story began. ( well actually the T... 

My pleasure, HS. [nt]

 
 By: amanico : November 22nd, 2017-01:33

The dials have the same dimensions ...

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : November 22nd, 2017-01:14
And are interchangeable... Interesting point, Nicolas. I always thought the black E 855 was inspired to the Polaris 65 dial. But if the timeline you state is true, then most passable scenario would be. white E 855 White -> Polaris 65 -> E 855 Black. It ex... 

That claim seems to b e totally foolish IMHO

 
 By: Clavi : November 22nd, 2017-02:36
Ordering 'special dials' was certainly not a thing back in 1968 with JLC (nor has it been much since). Plus, what would be the rationale. I claim BS on that story (as I suspect you do ! )

Well, the black dial for the E855 is just the same dial as the white E855... but in black

 
 By: Clavi : November 22nd, 2017-03:13
I don't see a connection between the 1965 polaris dial and the E855 black dial, at least no in this way... If you remember the 2010 exhibition of 40 memovoxes at Artcurial, there was a certified 1961 black E855 memovox with the JL at 12 (back serial numbe... 

Not totally the same. Double indices at 9 and 6 o clock, no 6 and 9 applied hour markers, and I didn't pay attention to the black E 855 With the applied 12!

 
 By: amanico : November 22nd, 2017-04:51
I just had a look at my pictures during the exhibition, I don't find it... You have it? Best, Nicolas

DIal of black and white E855 are the same, and they predate the 1965 Polaris

 
 By: Clavi : November 22nd, 2017-07:05
from your very own report of the Artcurial even in 2010, see the black 1961 E855: and also here, along with another 1961 white dial : ...  

I have seen a pic of the watch...

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : November 22nd, 2017-02:46
But not in real. Hard to see that as real, but in the same time, hard to understand why one would make it up... Since the owner is not trying to sell the watch and would make more money on putting in a scrappy Polaris 68... I have tried to get the story c...