Watch Independent Testers Discussion
Discussion

Watch Independent Testers Discussion

By El Padre · Oct 8, 2023 · 42 replies
El Padre
WPS member · Horological Meandering forum
42 replies5272 views1 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

El Padre's original post raises a critical question for luxury watch enthusiasts: how do we find truly independent, unbiased reviews in a landscape dominated by sponsored content? This discussion explores the challenges faced by reviewers in maintaining objectivity and the impact of brand relationships on editorial integrity. It's a timely reflection on media ethics within the horological community.

42 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →
We can find a large number of people on the internet (YouTube, Instagram, web, etc.) who talk about watches. They present them and give their opinions.
Ok... but as most of us know, a large part of these people are paid influencers, people who are associated with certain brands, labels, shops, and so on.

Do you know any independent magazines or people who test watches? Who talks about the advantages and disadvantages of watches, backed up by test results?

(Photo credit to Witschi)


Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
@L
@lberti
Oct 8, 2023

.... but he has been quiet for a while. On his last video he said that i wanted to move to UAE and do it from there. Lets see.

PA
patrick_y
Oct 8, 2023

Magazines rely upon support from the brands and advertising revenue of the brand. Thus, they're impacted when they're overly negative. Here at WPS, our moderators are never told to "cover up the truth" although we do try to be "constructive" with our criticism. Because if we're too negative, the brand may not invite us back! Is there really someone on YouTube who really knows what they're talking about? Yes. Do they make good videos? No, most of them are long winded and never get to their "point

DE
Derreck
Oct 8, 2023

Even though I am not very experienced on the issue, I will be watching this discussion closely to see what our more knowledgeable and experienced members are thinking 💭

EL
El Padre
Oct 8, 2023

The fear that a brand may no longer invite you to a show, premiere, or reception. It would be useful to have someone, perhaps anonymous, perhaps with a lot of followers, who is not afraid to speak about watches as they are. In the automotive sector, Mat from CarWow is doing a very good job.

EN
enjoythemusic
Oct 8, 2023

I have re-regulated a $300 Timex to +/-4 seconds a day. Of course regulation does take effort/time.

PI
piccolochimico (aka dsgalaxy1)
Oct 8, 2023

Here we are. The social media are hit & run by definition, one photo and that's it.

Advertisement

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Horological Meandering forum with 42 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →