WPS member · Horological Meandering forum
46 replies6468 views3 photos
Horo_Traveler initiates a fascinating comparison of ultra-thin watchmaking, spotlighting the Jaeger-LeCoultre Master Ultra Thin (MUT) 34 and the Citizen Eco-Drive One. This discussion delves into the engineering marvels behind these slim profiles and prompts a broader conversation among collectors about the practicalities and aesthetic appeal of ultra-thin timepieces in daily wear. Horo_Traveler's original post, enriched with illustrative images, serves as a springboard for exploring the nuanced world of horological thinness.
Different approaches to ultra thin watches.
JLC MUT 34 @ 5.3mm and Citizen Eco Drive One @ 3.1mm.



Key Points from the Discussion
- The JLC Master Ultra Thin movement, specifically the Calibre 849, is a remarkable feat of engineering, with its entire train on a single plane, contributing to its slender profile and 3.65mm case thickness. This design, while impressive, still accommodates a mainspring for a 48-hour power reserve.
- The Citizen Eco-Drive One, with its 1.0mm thick Calibre 8826, achieves an astonishing overall thickness of 3.1mm, leveraging solar power to eliminate battery changes and a two-hand display to maintain a classic aesthetic despite its quartz heart. However, some design choices, like the prominent brand name, could be refined.
- Ultra-thin watches offer a distinct wearing experience, often leading collectors to question the necessity of overly thick cases and numerous complications in their other timepieces. The ease of winding and adjusting a thin watch's crown is a critical design consideration.
- While admiring the craftsmanship of thin movements, there's a point where extreme thinness can raise concerns about a watch's durability and suitability for everyday wear, potentially making them feel too delicate for anything beyond formal occasions.
- The JLC Calibre 849, a manual-wind movement, is indeed a JLC creation, renowned for its slimness and traditional Swiss-lever escapement, making it a benchmark in ultra-thin mechanical watchmaking.
- The contrast between ultra-thin watches and larger, 'tuna can' style watches highlights diverse aesthetic preferences, where the latter might be appreciated for evoking vintage pocket watch designs and achieving a balanced diameter-to-height ratio despite their bulk.
Advertisement
Continue the conversation
This thread is active on the Horological Meandering forum with 46 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.
Join the Discussion →