Tudor Black Bay, Pelagos, Ranger Models Guide
Reference Guide

Tudor Black Bay, Pelagos, Ranger Models Guide

By quattro · Apr 24, 2025 · 31 replies
quattro
WPS member · Rolex forum
31 replies5815 views27 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

Emmanuel, known as quattro on WatchProSite, offers a hands-on review of five Tudor models, providing invaluable insights for collectors considering these references. His detailed observations, particularly on wearability and aesthetic nuances, serve as a critical resource for understanding Tudor's current lineup. This article distills his initial impressions and the community's subsequent discussion, highlighting key considerations for each watch.

31 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →
A few weeks ago, I visited a Tudor Boutique and here's what I was able to have a look at.


1/ The PELAGOS ULTRA, ref. M2543C1A7NU-0001 powered by Calibre MT5612-U

As surprising as it may seem from someone like me who is very much focused on colored gold dress watches, I've always loved the Pelagos and have been tempted by the regular blue dial variant (ref. M25600TB-0001).

The 43 x 14.5 mm case of the Ultra is unfortunately too large for my wrist, but I liked it very much nonetheless: the matte black dial with light green "Pelagos" looks aesthetically perfect and I liked very much the fact that the notched inner minutes flange that frames the applied markers on the regular versions has been replaced with a more classic angled réhaut. Lastly, contrarily to many Black Bay models, the Pelagos Ultra has kept its snowflake seconds hand (not replaced by a lollypop).

So, it's really a diver I wish I could pull off better...















As a comparison, here's how the 42 x 14.3 mm case of the regular blue version (ref. M25600TB-0001) and the 39 x 11.8 mm case of the Pelagos 39 (ref. M25407N-0001) looks on my wrist (sorry for the bad screenshots of videos from 2023). 









The Pelagos 39 is of course much more suited to my smallish wrist, but I personally dislike the sunburst black dial.








2/ The OPALINE DIAL BLACK BAY PRO, ref. M79470-0006 powered by Calibre MT5652

This watch looks really nice, but I found it a bit too thick for its size (39 x 14.6 mm) and preferred the black dial variant (ref. M79470-0001), which I could also try on.
















3/ The BLACK BAY 54, ref. M79000N-0001 powered by Calibre MT5400

Even if the fit (37 x 11.2 mm) was perfect for my wrist, I didn't respond at all to the shape and aesthetic of this watch: the lugs seem to me to be excessively long for the restrained diameter of the dial and bezel. And the vintage vibe, which Tudor has created very successfully on other models, somehow felt a bit "artificial" to me on this particular one (just my feeling of course). Also, I personally like the lollypop seconds hands with its round ended counterweight less than the snowflake seconds hand (which, sadly, is progressively replaced by the lollypop one on many Black Bay models).








4/ The RANGER ref. M79950-0001 powered by Calibre MT5402

The fit (39 x 12 mm) was good, but the "field watch" aesthetic, even if very well executed, didn't speak to me.








5/ The BLACK BAY 58 BRONZE ref. M79012M-0001 powered by Calibre MT5400

To say that I liked this particular timepiece would be an understatement: I loved it to the point that I was tempted to buy it instantly. Why? Because I'm enamoured with warm colors and the bronze case and bracelet with the brown dial and bezel felt absolutely wonderful to me (btw, the case is 39 x 11.9 mm).

I wasn't able to try on the complementary "brown-bronze" fabric strap with yellow center-line which comes with it, but I could try on the 925 Silver variant with its taupe fabric strap (ref. M79010SG-0002) and it convinced me that it would look absolutely perfect (see photos below).

I know that bronze tarnishes and I've even heard some owners say that this bronze watch ends up smelling like the metal variant of a wet dog, but it was by far my favorite, with the Pelagos Ultra.















Thanks for reading!

Best, Emmanuel

About the Audemars Piguet Black Bay Ref. 5400

The Audemars Piguet Royal Oak "Jumbo" reference 5400, introduced in 1972, is a foundational model for the brand and the broader luxury sports watch category. It was designed by Gérald Genta and distinguished by its integrated bracelet and octagonal bezel secured by eight visible hexagonal screws. This reference established the core aesthetic that would define the Royal Oak collection for decades, emphasizing a blend of industrial design and high-end finishing.

The 5400 features a relatively thin profile for its time, housing the ultra-thin automatic Caliber 2121 movement. The case construction, often in stainless steel, utilized a monobloc design for water resistance, with the bezel and case back secured to the mid-case. The dial typically featured a "Tapisserie" pattern, adding texture and depth, protected by a sapphire crystal.

As the original Royal Oak, the 5400 holds significant appeal for collectors interested in horological history and design innovation. Its enduring design language and technical specifications set a benchmark for a new genre of watches. Variants exist in different metals, though the steel version remains particularly sought after for its historical significance and purity of design.

Specifications

Caliber
Caliber 2121
Case
Stainless steel
Diameter
39mm
Dial
Blue
Water Resist.
50m
Crystal
Sapphire

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
MA
Marc Obermann
Apr 24, 2025
Most of those are really nice but all of them need to go on a serious diet.

OK so I get the Pelagos Ultra is a WR of 1000m but the rest are mostly just 200m WR and again most are just simple 3 handers why do they need to be so thick? The only thing I can think of is that Rolex mandate this to stop Tudor from eating their lunch and stealing all their business. Marc

QU
quattro
Apr 24, 2025
I agree that some are really too thick.

And maybe thickness is indeed a way to "protect" Rolex... Best, Emmanuel

MA
Mary Anny
Apr 24, 2025
In one way or another, it has always been like that!

SE
seabas132
Apr 24, 2025
I agree.

The more I am looking at different watches, the more thinness is becoming a more important factor.

MA
Mary Anny
Apr 24, 2025
Thanks for sharing the photos and your impressions.

I look forward to seeing the new 58, especially a black-dial version, if they ever make one!

QU
quattro
Apr 24, 2025
I suppose you mean the one with a Burgundy dial.

I personally didn't like the glowy dial and didn't even ask to try it on. But I've posted some live photos found online here if you want to have a look. Best, Emmanuel

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Rolex forum with 31 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →