Rolex Submariner vs. GMT-Master II Comparison
Collection

Rolex Submariner vs. GMT-Master II Comparison

By sham1 · Jun 3, 2022 · 76 replies
sham1
WPS member · Horological Meandering forum
76 replies11936 views5 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

In this insightful post, sham1 shares his recent acquisitions: a Vacheron Constantin American 1921 and a Kikuchi Nakagawa Murakumo. His reflections offer a unique perspective on the allure of dress watches from both established luxury brands and burgeoning independents, highlighting the distinct charm and appeal each brings to a collection. sham1's experience underscores the evolving landscape of watch collecting, where patience and a keen eye for craftsmanship are paramount.

I have been terribly busy of late and I would normally post photos of a watch as soon as I receive it but these two had to wait.  On Monday my Vacheron Constantin American 1921 arrived after I had purchased ir from London last week.  It always makes sense to ship a watch out of the UK to save on the twenty percent VAT and instead pay the local tax which is four times less (for me anyway).  This 36.5mm manual winding Vacheron never made its way to the Malaysian authorised dealiers hence my having to source it from overseas.  It is my first and possibly last ever Vacheron as many of you know, I am more inclined to buy a Patek.. But this 1921 is quite something else with its slim cushion case and well finished manual winding movement.  A classy acquistion if I have to say so myself and definitely a keeper.

Then on Tuesday, the long awaited Murakumo by Kikuchi Nakagawa finally arrived. When I say 'long awaited', many of you will squirm that I received my watch 13 months after placing my order.  If one were to browse through their website, the waiting time has increased to an incredible 108 months, I repeat that is 9 years ladies and gentlemen.  So in the past 13 months, the watchmaking world has gone a bit mad to say the least!   The Murakumo with tons of black polishing is a 36.8mm watch with a Vaucher 5401 automatic movement.  It is so much lighter than the Vacheron (the VC is in white gold) and the soft alligator strap adds to the comfort.  I love the off white dial (as I do the Vacheron) and the service shown to me by Mr Yusuke Kikuchi was exemplary.  We sometimes take for granted what good packaging entails but I have to say that I have never received a watch that has been packaged so well - for a moment when I received it, I was clueless as to where to start opening it!  smile

So for those of you who don't know me - I have a weakness for dress watches especially ones with Breguet hands and numerals.  The Murakumo may not have Breguet hands but I think you will agree with me that it has an abundance of charm.  I am blessed to own these two masterpieces, arguably my favourite dress watches, one from a mainstream brand and fthe other from ain independent.

Thank you for reading and have a pleasant weekend.






Nope, not twins!




While you are driving, the position of the numbers make it easier to read




A tribute to the Patek 96 but arguably more refined




An example of a perfectly legible watch!




The wide strap may not to everyone’s liking but it is supple and ultra comfortable and is a tribute to the Pateks of the 30s and 40s.


About the Vacheron Constantin Historiques Ref. American1921

The Vacheron Constantin Historiques American 1921 is a distinctive reinterpretation of a cushion-shaped watch originally produced by the manufacture for the American market in the 1920s. This reference is characterized by its unique diagonal display, with the crown positioned at the 1 o'clock position and the dial rotated 45 degrees clockwise. This design was historically intended to allow drivers to read the time without removing their hands from the steering wheel, offering both a functional and aesthetically unconventional presentation within the Historiques collection.

This particular iteration of the American 1921 features a case crafted from precious metal, often rose gold, with a polished finish that highlights its cushion shape and stepped bezel. The watch is typically fitted with a manual-winding mechanical movement, visible through a sapphire crystal case back, providing a power reserve suitable for daily wear. The crystal protecting the dial is also sapphire, ensuring clarity and scratch resistance.

The American 1921 appeals to collectors seeking pieces with historical provenance and an unconventional design. Its distinctive orientation and vintage inspiration make it a conversation piece and a unique offering within Vacheron Constantin's contemporary lineup. Various sizes have been produced, catering to different wrist preferences while maintaining the core design principles of the original 1921 model.

Specifications

Caliber
Caliber 4400 AS
Case
18k rose gold
Diameter
40mm
Dial
Silver
Water Resist.
30m
Crystal
Sapphire

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
MA
mahesh
Jun 3, 2022

Sham - you're too kind to break my heart into exact two pieces ;-) both of them are stunning - I believe the case finish of KN would be extremely high. Best, mahesh.,

SH
sham1
Jun 3, 2022

but you know how careful I am with my watches so it suits me well. Best of all, both watches have exceeded my expectations. It is always a risk to buy a watch based on photos but the Murakumo would easily rank as one of my top 5 purchases of all time even with the concealed movement. Afterall, it is the dial that we see all the time so for me that is what counts the most.

SH
sham1
Jun 3, 2022

Being on a roll has happened too many times with me fortunately or unfortunately but I believe my watch buying days are coming to a close, not because the passion has died but mainly due to my having almost all that I desire when it comes to watches. I don't think I shall be ordering any more new pieces as I have a possible seven more incoming watches over the nbext couple of years. I would like to say 'enough' so if I do post any more than seven new watches, please give me a stern warning!!

GC
gcsk76
Jun 3, 2022

Also nice to see you again in UK

BI
BigAppleBill
Jun 3, 2022

Congrats on two great additions to your collection!

SH
sham1
Jun 3, 2022

See you again hopefully in KL!

Advertisement

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Horological Meandering forum with 76 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →