Collection
Emmanuel, known as quattro on WatchProSite, initiates a compelling comparison between two distinct Patek Philippe limited editions: the Calatrava ref. 5565A-001 and the Gondolo ref. 5100P-001. His original post, rich with detailed imagery, invites collectors to weigh in on these significant celebration timepieces. This article synthesizes the community's diverse perspectives on design, movement, and wearability, offering valuable insights for both seasoned enthusiasts and new collectors exploring Patek Philippe's horological legacy.
The Patek Philippe Calatrava reference 5100 was introduced in 2000 as a limited edition to commemorate the new millennium. This reference stands out within the Calatrava line for its distinctive 'Manta Ray' shaped case, departing from the more traditional round Calatrava forms. It was produced in very limited quantities across different precious metals, making it a notable special edition for collectors of the brand.
The 5100 features a manual-wind caliber 28-20/220, a movement specifically developed for this model, known for its elongated form to fit the unique case shape. The case is characterized by its rectangular, slightly curved profile with integrated lugs, and it is fitted with a sapphire crystal. The specific variant mentioned, the 5100P-001, is crafted in platinum.
This reference appeals to collectors who appreciate Patek Philippe's limited-production commemorative pieces and those drawn to watches with distinctive case designs. Its unique aesthetic and the bespoke movement developed for it position the 5100 as a significant, albeit unconventional, entry in the brand's modern history, particularly for enthusiasts of shaped timepieces.
Always loved this case shape.
However, I want to throw in an argument on behalf of the 5565. There are rare occasions on which I think, "What if I quit collecting watches and just wore one flexible fine watch every day?" And on those occasions I think that the 5565 would be an ideal candidate for that one watch.
The Calatrava is a beauty - I especially love the syringe hands and it’s SS. But I find the 5100 so much more special. 10 day power reserve alone is an incredible achievement. The movement is beautiful and case design is pure class. It’s a dream.
My vote goes for the 5565A, due to a more special look wearability and legibility. I owned the 5100G and sold it with no regrets. While the movement is very special and visually very appealing, the legibility was close to zero and due to the curving middle case, it was a scratch magnet. Yes, more “flex”, but the 5565A is for “the once who know, now”
But it all depends on what one considers an every day watch: I, for example, wear the Chronometro Gondolo daily and would rather wear the 5100 than the 5565. But I know it's just me, and the 5565 is of course closer to the usual definition of an every day watch! Best, Emmanuel
Very well said. Best, Emmanuel
This thread is active on the Patek Philippe forum with 68 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.
Join the Discussion →
