Patek Philippe
Vintage

Patek Philippe "Manta Ray" Case: Vintage Review

By quattro · Dec 18, 2024 · 12 replies
quattro
WPS member · Patek Philippe forum
12 replies2765 views29 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

quattro's exploration of Patek Philippe's 'manta ray' cases, specifically the vintage Ref. 2554 and its modern successor, the Ref. 5100, offers a unique perspective on design evolution. His detailed comparison highlights the subtle nuances that define these iconic timepieces, inviting collectors to appreciate the historical context and aesthetic choices behind Patek Philippe's distinctive case architecture. This article delves into why the original 'manta ray' continues to captivate enthusiasts.

The case of Patek Philippe's ref. 2554, with its angular flared sides resembling the wings of a manta ray, hence its moniker, is one of the most sensuous I know.

It was the direct source of inspiration of the later ref. 5100, made to celebrate the year 2000. 

Because of its thinner and subtler profile, I personally prefer the 1950 ref. 2554 to the modern ref. 5100.

Have a nice day!


A/ Ref. 2554 with caliber 9-90

1/ Rose gold























credit: fabsuisse vintage watch 


2/ Yellow gold  

Watch by Patek Philippe, gondolo



credit: ponti collection

Watch by Patek Philippe, gon



credit: parthian watch company 


3/ White gold

Watch by Patek Philippe, gondolo

credit: phillips 


4/ Platinum

Watch by Patek Philippe, gondolo

credit: monaco legend auctions 


Watch by Patek Philippe, gondolo

credit: phillips 


B/ Ref. 5100 Gondolo 10 Days Millenium Limited Edition with caliber 28-20/220

1/ Yellow gold ref. 5100J-001

Watch by Patek Philippe, gondolo

credit: bonhams


2/ White gold ref. 5100G-001

Watch by Patek Philippe, gondolo

credit: s.song


3/ Platinum ref. 5100P-001

Watch by Patek Philippe, gondolo

Watch by Patek Philippe, gondolo

credit: @aleartuso.italy 


4/ Rose gold ref. 5100R-001

Watch by Patek Philippe, gondolo

Watch by Patek Philippe, gondolo

Watch by Patek Philippe, gondolo

Watch by Patek Philippe, gondolo

Watch by Patek Philippe, gondolo

credit: watch-out & patek-philippe.blogspot.hk 

About the Patek Philippe Calatrava Ref. 5100

The Patek Philippe Calatrava reference 5100 was introduced in 2000 as a limited edition to commemorate the new millennium. This reference stands out within the Calatrava line for its distinctive 'Manta Ray' shaped case, departing from the more traditional round Calatrava forms. It was produced in very limited quantities across different precious metals, making it a notable special edition for collectors of the brand.

The 5100 features a manual-wind caliber 28-20/220, a movement specifically developed for this model, known for its elongated form to fit the unique case shape. The case is characterized by its rectangular, slightly curved profile with integrated lugs, and it is fitted with a sapphire crystal. The specific variant mentioned, the 5100P-001, is crafted in platinum.

This reference appeals to collectors who appreciate Patek Philippe's limited-production commemorative pieces and those drawn to watches with distinctive case designs. Its unique aesthetic and the bespoke movement developed for it position the 5100 as a significant, albeit unconventional, entry in the brand's modern history, particularly for enthusiasts of shaped timepieces.

Specifications

Caliber
Cal. 28-20/220
Case
Platinum
Diameter
34mm x 46mm
Dial
Silver
Water Resist.
25m
Crystal
Sapphire

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
GL
GLau
Dec 18, 2024

delicious 😋! Thanks for this interesting post !👍

MB
mblum3
Dec 18, 2024

If I had to decide between the 2554 or the 5100 it would be a very tough call. The simplicity of the 2554 dial and as you say the thinner profile and subtlety of the case is very appealing. My favorite of the 5100 is the white gold. Never tried one on though.

QU
quattro
Dec 18, 2024

Jokes apart, the 2554 is really fantastic. Thanks for looking.

QU
quattro
Dec 18, 2024

but the thickness of the case is a real problem for me: something of the fluidity (the swimming manta ray) is completely lost. I will try to see both in real life someday. Truly fascinating models.

QU
quattro
Dec 18, 2024

and I really think I would choose the 2554. Anyway, quite fascinating pieces. Thanks for looking.

QU
quattro
Dec 18, 2024

The older model wins my heat too! Thanks for looking.

Advertisement

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Patek Philippe forum with 12 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →