Patek Philippe 5990 vs. 5172: A Collector's Trade Dilemma
Discussion

Patek Philippe 5990 vs. 5172: A Collector's Trade Dilemma

By Mikesr · Jul 29, 2020 · 21 replies
Mikesr
WPS member · Patek Philippe forum
21 replies3598 views1 photos
f 𝕏 in πŸ’¬ βœ‰ πŸ”—

Mikesr, a seasoned collector, recently sparked a lively debate within the WatchProSite community by posing a compelling question: should he trade his Patek Philippe Nautilus Ref. 5990 for a Ref. 5172? This scenario highlights the complex decisions collectors face when presented with an opportunity from their authorized dealer, balancing personal preference, market value, and strategic collection planning. His query offers a valuable lens into the contemporary Patek Philippe collecting landscape.

21 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →
I’d like your opinions please, and thanks. My beloved AD called and said he’d received a 5172 patek, and if I want , he would trade even up for my 5990 nautilus. I’m thinking no. Thanks in advance .



About the Patek Philippe Nautilus Travel Time Chronograph Ref. 5990

Patek Philippe Nautilus Travel Time Chronograph Reference 5990

The reference 5990 represents Patek Philippe's combination of travel time and chronograph functions within the Nautilus collection. This stainless steel variant features a blue dial configuration, positioning it as a sports complication piece within the brand's portfolio during its 2014-2018 production period.

The 40.5mm stainless steel case houses the automatic caliber CH 28-520 C FUS movement, delivering 45-55 hours of power reserve. Technical specifications include sapphire crystal protection, 120-meter water resistance, and a smooth bezel design. The watch is completed with a stainless steel bracelet matching the case material.

This reference appeals to collectors seeking dual complications in a steel sports watch format. The blue dial variant offers color distinction within the 5990 series, while the four-year production window establishes its position as a limited-period offering. The combination of travel time and chronograph functions targets users requiring both timing and dual time zone capabilities.

Specifications

Caliber
CH 28-520 C FUS
Case
Stainless Steel
Diameter
40.5 mm
Dial
Blue
Water Resist.
120m
Crystal
Sapphire

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
CH
chris7509
Jul 29, 2020

i believe the 5990 is harder to get in general than a 5172 ... So, unless you loooovve the 5172 ... just looking at chrono24 you can find 5172 with about 10k less than retail price .... so i guess the ad would make a good trade in this case

FA
FabR
Jul 29, 2020

The current MSRP is roughly $41k for the 5712 vs. $55k for the 5990. The best solution would of course be to just purchase the 5712, if you have a chance, without giving up on this beauty... They would both fit nicely into the same collection ;-) Keep us posted!

TH
Thomahof
Jul 29, 2020

I think he said 5172. That's an appealing trade to me, anyhow. Thomas

PA
Patekfinity
Jul 29, 2020

One would assume the trade is fair due to msrp of 5990 being lower than the 5172...but real secondary market prices on the 5990 is actually higher than the 5172. If I were to trade that in I would request for an allocation on a 5711 in addition to the 5172. Basically you will trade the 5990 for a 5172 and the next in line purchase of a 5711. Then you won’t miss out on your sports watch!

FA
FabR
Jul 29, 2020

But personally, while I like the 5172, again I probably wouldn't permute a 5990 for it...πŸ˜‰πŸ‘

BU
BuffaloWatch
Jul 29, 2020

Especially if you love the 5990

Advertisement

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Patek Philippe forum with 21 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →