Collection
glimmer shares his experience visiting an Authorized Dealer to compare the Patek Philippe Ref. 5227 and Ref. 5146, seeking clarity for his next acquisition. His post captures the dilemma many collectors face when choosing between iconic references, highlighting the subtle differences in dial aesthetics and case design. This article delves into his impressions and the community's diverse recommendations.
The 5146P is absolutely gorgeous but the 5227R felt like there was too much “space”on the dial, however, I really love the curvaceous case and lugs and really wonder how this would look in the black dial. 
The Patek Philippe Calatrava Reference 5107 represents the Officer's Case variant within the Calatrava collection, distinguished by its hinged dust cover design. This reference was produced from 2006 to 2010, offering collectors a traditional officer's watch configuration in the classic Calatrava format.
The 5107 features a 36mm case available in 18k yellow gold or 18k white gold, fitted with a smooth bezel and sapphire crystal. The manual-wind Caliber 215 PS movement provides 44 hours of power reserve. Dial options include ivory, silver, or black finishes, paired with a leather strap. Water resistance is rated to 30 meters.
This reference appeals to collectors seeking a traditional officer's case configuration with the protective hinged dust cover. The 36mm sizing and manual movement positioning make it suitable for those preferring classic proportions and traditional winding mechanisms. The limited four-year production window and multiple material options provide collecting depth within this specific Calatrava variant.
Since you own already a 5107 Calatrava to upgrade would be not to my liking. You have good value with the 5107 its a screw down crown , so water resistance would be better. Unless you want to add a Calatrava to your collection. My opinion. Cheers! Geross.
I would have three PP’s in my collection (5711, 5107) Perhaps having those three would give me time to consider whether I want to keep all or sell the 5107 in favor of a WG Daytona.
Let me throw few options in the mix. I prefer 5196 in white gold. It's slimmer and less expensive with much more interesting dial with the vertical grain pattern( unfortunately hard to see in pictures) Definitely worth seeing if you don't mind manual wind and closed back. It's also 37mm instead of 39mm Other option would be 5146 in white gold with Tiffany dial. You'll have to go to Tiffany that sells Patek but price will not vary and you'll have much more special dial. There's no doubt that the
And good advice. Thank you for your input.
It's my pleasure!
I find myself swimming in the combination of dial layout and color. Perhaps a bit monotonous?? Having written that, I really love Roberto’s suggestions. The WG metal and dial works better IMO, and the Tiffany dial AC offers a little something special if you’re so inclined
2,850 Patek Philippe listings are live on the eBay market and 1721 collector listings on the WatchProSite marketplace.
This thread is active on the Patek Philippe forum with 17 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.
Join the Discussion →
