WPS member · Patek Philippe forum
40 replies11707 views2 photos
In a perennial debate among Patek Philippe collectors, patekvcap seeks community input on a significant choice between two distinguished chronographs: the Ref. 5170P and the Ref. 5172G. This discussion highlights the nuanced considerations that go into acquiring a high-complication timepiece, from case material and dial aesthetics to wrist presence and long-term collectibility. Readers gain insight into the subtle differences that define these highly coveted references.
I am kinda dont know what to do...
Which will you get ?
5170p or 5172g
I have seen and tried on both pieces before but i have not made up my mind ...
Any suggestion?
Pictures taken from the internet.
About the Patek Philippe Chronograph Ref. 5170
The Chronograph reference 5170, introduced in 2010, marked a significant development for Patek Philippe as it was the first serially produced chronograph to feature a fully in-house manufactured movement. This reference succeeded the reference 5070, transitioning from a Lemania-based caliber to a proprietary design, underscoring the brand's commitment to integrated manufacturing for its complications. It represents a modern interpretation of a classic chronograph layout within the Patek Philippe catalog.
The reference 5170 features a case measuring 39.4 mm in diameter and 10.9 mm in thickness, available in 18k white, rose, or yellow gold. It is equipped with the manual-winding caliber CH 29-535 PS, which offers a power reserve of 65 hours. The watch is fitted with a sapphire crystal and is water-resistant to 30 meters. The movement is visible through a sapphire case back, showcasing its intricate finishing.
This reference appeals to collectors seeking a contemporary Patek Philippe chronograph with an in-house movement. Early variants, such as the yellow gold reference 5170J-001, featured a pulsometer scale, which was later replaced by a minute track on subsequent iterations. The various metal options and dial configurations provide distinct aesthetic choices for collectors, reflecting different periods of its production run.
Specifications
- Caliber
- CH 29-535 PS
- Case
- 18k White Gold, Rose Gold, or Yellow Gold
- Diameter
- 39.4 mm
- Dial
- Silver, Black, or Opaline
- Water Resist.
- 30m
- Crystal
- Sapphire
About the Patek Philippe Chronograph Ref. 5172
The Patek Philippe Chronograph reference 5172 represents a contemporary interpretation of the classic manually wound chronograph within the brand's collection. It succeeded the reference 5170, introducing updated case proportions and dial aesthetics while retaining the traditional two-register chronograph layout. This reference is distinguished by its round pushers and a slightly larger case diameter, offering a modern presence on the wrist while honoring Patek Philippe's heritage in complicated watchmaking. It is a key offering for collectors seeking a pure chronograph function without additional complications.
The 5172 is typically presented in a precious metal case, housing the in-house caliber CH 29-535 PS. This manual-wind movement is visible through a sapphire crystal case back, showcasing its traditional architecture and finishing. The movement provides a substantial power reserve, ensuring reliable timekeeping and chronograph operation. The front crystal is also sapphire, protecting a dial designed for legibility with applied numerals and a pulsometer scale.
This reference appeals to collectors who appreciate Patek Philippe's commitment to traditional haute horlogerie and the art of the manually wound chronograph. Its design cues, such as the syringe hands and applied Breguet numerals, evoke vintage chronographs while being executed with contemporary precision. The 5172 stands as a testament to Patek Philippe's enduring capability in producing high-quality, in-house chronograph movements, positioning it as a significant piece for enthusiasts of complicated timepieces.
Specifications
- Caliber
- CH 29-535 PS
- Case
- 18k white gold
- Diameter
- 41mm
- Dial
- Blue
- Water Resist.
- 30m
- Crystal
- Sapphire
Key Points from the Discussion
- The Patek Philippe Ref. 5170P, at 39.4mm, offers a more compact fit compared to the 41mm Ref. 5172G, a crucial factor for wrist comfort and aesthetics. Its platinum case and beautifully changing blue dial are often cited as superior, with the diamond markers being discreet and understated.
- The 5170P's dial is particularly captivating in person, with photographs often failing to capture its full beauty and light-catching properties. Many collectors prefer it even over the 5070P, considering it a more compelling and less 'overhyped' reference.
- While the 5170P boasts a lovely blue dial and understated diamond indices, the 5172G counters with interesting syringe hands and an excellent strap. However, the platinum heft and feel on the wrist often give the 5170P a slight edge in terms of material preference.
- Both references share the same in-house movement, meaning movement quality is not a differentiating factor. The choice ultimately comes down to aesthetic preferences like case size, dial color resilience, and hand design.
- The 5170P is often considered a more special watch due to its gradient dial, platinum case, and stealthy diamond indices, which are only noticeable upon close inspection. The syringe hands of the 5172G are a point of personal preference, with some collectors not being fans.
- A significant purchase like this should stem from a strong personal desire rather than external influence. Collectors are advised to wait until they find a watch they 'must have,' trusting their gut feeling which has likely guided them successfully in other life decisions.
- The dial color of the 5172G can be challenging for some, especially when compared to other blue dials like those found on an Overseas. For the 5170, versions with Breguet numerals are often preferred.
Advertisement
Available on the marketplace
2,837 Patek Philippe listings are live on the eBay market and 1721 collector listings on the WatchProSite marketplace.
Continue the conversation
This thread is active on the Patek Philippe forum with 40 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.
Join the Discussion →
