Top 2 Luxury Watches: Which to Choose?
Discussion

Top 2 Luxury Watches: Which to Choose?

By smironov · Nov 16, 2024 · 28 replies
smironov
WPS member · Horological Meandering forum
28 replies2750 views4 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

In a captivating original post, smironov presents a horological dilemma, inviting the WatchProSite community to weigh in on two distinct 'horostars': the Patek Philippe Gondolo 5100 and a Girard-Perregaux Vintage 1945 Tourbillon. This article delves into the community's discerning opinions, highlighting the unique attributes that make each timepiece a compelling choice for collectors.

28 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →
Watch, Patek Philippe, gondolo, 5100

Watch, Girard Perregaux, Vintage 1945, 1945 Tourbillon


This message has been edited by India Whiskey Charlie on 2024-11-16 16:04:38

About the Patek Philippe Calatrava Ref. 5100

The Patek Philippe Calatrava reference 5100 was introduced in 2000 as a limited edition to commemorate the new millennium. This reference stands out within the Calatrava line for its distinctive 'Manta Ray' shaped case, departing from the more traditional round Calatrava forms. It was produced in very limited quantities across different precious metals, making it a notable special edition for collectors of the brand.

The 5100 features a manual-wind caliber 28-20/220, a movement specifically developed for this model, known for its elongated form to fit the unique case shape. The case is characterized by its rectangular, slightly curved profile with integrated lugs, and it is fitted with a sapphire crystal. The specific variant mentioned, the 5100P-001, is crafted in platinum.

This reference appeals to collectors who appreciate Patek Philippe's limited-production commemorative pieces and those drawn to watches with distinctive case designs. Its unique aesthetic and the bespoke movement developed for it position the 5100 as a significant, albeit unconventional, entry in the brand's modern history, particularly for enthusiasts of shaped timepieces.

Specifications

Caliber
Cal. 28-20/220
Case
Platinum
Diameter
34mm x 46mm
Dial
Silver
Water Resist.
25m
Crystal
Sapphire

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
KU
Kurt Behm
Nov 16, 2024

I owned the Patek in YG 20 years ago and it was spectacular. Without a doubt my choice. Good luck with your decision.

AM
amanico
Nov 16, 2024
Damn... Except the case shape, you cannot compare them. I would say both.

MC
MCG (Markus)
Nov 16, 2024
Uncomparable, right! 👍🏻 What do you choose apple or pineapple? 🤷🏼‍♂️🫣

If I had to choose than the GP of course… its history is unbeatable!

AM
amanico
Nov 16, 2024
Well, the Patek is quite unique ( movement and case )... But both is definitely the way to go.

EN
enjoythemusic
Nov 16, 2024
Well said, a proper movement in a non-round case. That is the way it is properly done 😎

Dad Stern cared, and it shows.

EN
enjoythemusic
Nov 16, 2024
So much to love... including the screws that 'line up' nicely.

Love the shaping so you see the entire wheel... and care enough to shape bits uniformly. They did produce a lot at 450 made, and PP took the time and effort for a proper movement.

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Horological Meandering forum with 28 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →