JLC Memovox or Deep Sea Chronograph?

nilomis · 2013-12-27T07:06:08Z

Nilomis asks for advice on his first JLC: Memovox Tribute to Deep Sea, Deep Sea Vintage Chronograph, Deep Sea Chronograph, or Master Hometime Aston Martin. Compare pros and cons.

nilomis

WPS member · Jaeger-LeCoultre forum

38 replies12262 views4 photos

Nilomis initiates a compelling 'This or That' discussion, seeking community input on his first Jaeger-LeCoultre acquisition for 2014. His detailed breakdown of pros and cons for four distinct JLC models — including the Memovox Tribute to Deep Sea and various Deep Sea Chronographs — provides a valuable framework for collectors weighing similar choices.

38 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →

Team,

I decided that my first watch of 2014 will be a JLC.

I'm doing a small reshuffle on my small stable and I can get one of those.

The big question is what should I pic (only one, of course):

1) Memovox Tribute to Deep Sea ref. 2028470

Pros: Iconic, alarm, 40.5mm size, acrylic crystal, vintage look

Cons: I never use any alarm based on a watch. I prefer to trust on my smart phone.

2) Jaeger-LeCoultre Deep Sea Vintage Chronograph ref. 207857J

Pros: Vintage look, chronograph, two barrels, power reserve of 65 hours

Cons: "Static" sub dials (only run with the chronograph active)

3) Jaeger-LeCoultre Deep Sea Chronograph ref. 2068570

Pros: Chronograph, two barrels, power reserve of 65 hours

Cons: Not vintage look

4) Master Hometime Aston Martin ref. 162847N

Pros: More "dressy", second time zone indicator, 40mm

Cons: Aston Martin reference (I don't own one and I don't plan to own), power reserve.

Please advise.

Cheers,

Nilo

Key Points from the Discussion

The Memovox Tribute to Deep Sea (TT DSA) is a beautiful piece, but its 45-hour power reserve is a drawback compared to the longer power reserves of chronograph options.
The TT DSA's strap and pin buckle were perceived as a mismatch and of insufficient quality, despite the strap being soft.
Co-branded watches, like the Aston Martin Master Hometime, are often less appealing unless the collaboration results in a truly original and unique timepiece, such as the Amvox II.
The TT DSA is a classic, timeless, and beautiful watch that collectors will be proud to own for years, making it a strong contender despite the alarm function not being a personal priority.
The Master Hometime is a good choice for its simplicity and second time zone, but its utility depends on the owner's travel habits and existing collection.
The small pin buckle on the TT DSA is faithful to the original design, which did not allow space for a JLC engraving.

The Discussion

amanico

Dec 27, 2013

Easy for me: TT DSA.

The reporduction of an icon, and an Alamr Watch ,which, believe me, is much more trustful than your Phone Alarm. At least, you won't depend of a battery to Wake up! And it is much sexier than a Cell Phone! Best, Nicolas.

nilomis

Dec 27, 2013

Any experience with the three sub dialed chronograph?

I'm curious to learn more about this movement. Cheers Nilo

hs111

Dec 27, 2013

+1 on DSA - "EU"= Less is more+ Icon ..If Chrono, 2 counters..

- That was for the "DSA" famille.. JLC Home- time not a bad choice, simple; how much needed 2nd time ( other travel watches ?) Just my humble 2 cents Good luck and happy reasoning ! ;) Best, hs

jml_watches

Dec 28, 2013

I agree with Nicolas! [nt]

Jester

Dec 27, 2013

DSA gets my vote s well...

Timeless beauty, need I say more?

Ruckdee

Dec 27, 2013

Number 1 2 3 4 in that order for me. So my answer is number 1! [nt]