
Nicolas (amanico) provides his initial impressions of the Jaeger-LeCoultre Master Grande Tradition Minute Repeater from SIHH 2015, highlighting its refined aesthetics and a new generation minute repeater movement. He praises the daring yet smart decision to offer it in a 39mm case, contributing to an elegant and understated charm, despite a few reservations.
If I compare this watch to i.e. Patek 5078P or the relatively new VC Minute Repeater, it is quite far away. Everything depends of course on the price. A minute Repeater is such a great and rare complication that one would expect plain perfection when the finishing of the movement is concerned. Even the oscillating weight does not look too nice. I agree about the gold ring around the seconds and the funny plate at around 5 o'clock looks very much out of place. But: JLC made in the past affordable
I must say I like the overall look of this MGT, especially the markings, the hands and the very nice white dial finish we already saw on other JLCs. There are just 3 things I would have liked to be different: . The "plaque" which looks a little too big. You explained why it is so, maybe in the metal it looks less important. . The MR activator looks very big compared to the case and I much prefer the ultra thin one presented last year. . The movement, for a MR is not visually very impressive, I u
The combination of clean aesthetics and frosted dial is very appealing. The base movement looks like it shares quite a bit in common with the accessible pieces in the Master series. Given JLC's capabilities, there's no doubt the movement could be finished to a much higher level, but consider at the success JLC had with the steel Master Tourbillon. If the price of the minute repeater is a similar bargain, a larger number of collectors will be able to consider purchasing one. That's not typical fo
Not mechanically, but aesthetically. Best, Nicolas
I am not sure about the movement. For me, a Minute Repeater is magic, and the movement should match with that magic spirit. The HM 11 has an interesting and nice movement. This one doesn't reach that level of finish. Not because it is automatic, just because I am not impressed by the finish. Best, Mark. Nicolas
Hi I think I'm in agreement with other comments made earlier. The dial is wonderful, though agree about the gold ring around the small seconds. The texture of the dial adds real depth and I really like the restraint of the markers. I also agree with you with the plaque - I think it detracts from the elegance of the watch. Personally if it has to be there - i'td be nice if it followed the Rendez vous repeater with the plaque at 6 and perhaps with the Jaeger le Coultre on it rather than sonnerie o
This thread is active on the Jaeger-LeCoultre forum with 20 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.
Join the Discussion →