Girard-Perregaux Constant Escapement Black vs. White

crown comfort · 2017-09-06T00:38:39Z

Compare the 2017 Girard-Perregaux Constant Escapement in black ceramic vs. white gold. Discover aesthetic updates, wearability, and collector preferences for this innovative timepiece.

crown comfort

WPS member · Girard Perregaux forum

34 replies3710 views5 photos

Crown comfort initiates a compelling discussion on the 2017 Girard-Perregaux Constant Escapement, focusing on the aesthetic and wearability updates to this technically advanced timepiece. The author prompts the community to weigh in on the preference between the all-black and white gold versions, highlighting the subtle design changes and their impact on the watch's presence on the wrist. This post serves as an excellent comparison guide for collectors considering this innovative reference.

34 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →

Friends,

this year, GP slightly updated the amazing Constant Escapement. Now all versions are 46mm and almost wearable for a smallish wrist.

Slight updates had been made on the dials and for the all black version.

So the question is, which one do you prefer?

The all black?

Or the White Gold now with grey dial?

For me, I very much prefer the white gold version (damn that makes this dream even less reachable) as it combines the sophistication of white gold precious metal with the technical modernity, a contrast I like.

And even the white gold is of course much much heavier, for some reason, it sits better on my wrist. I did notice some very minor differences on the case construction and wonder if that is the reason.

So which one would you pick?

Key Points from the Discussion

The 2017 Girard-Perregaux Constant Escapement models are all 46mm, making them more wearable for smaller wrists despite their size.
The white gold version with a grey dial is preferred by the author for its sophisticated contrast between precious metal and technical modernity, and it surprisingly sits better on the wrist despite being heavier.
Beyond black and white gold, other versions of the Constant Escapement include a black case with a non-all-black dial, Pink Gold, and Titanium, offering a wide range of choices.
The white gold version is generally favored for its superior contrast, which better enhances the 'Triple Bridges' and the hour sub-dial.
The all-black version of the Constant Escapement is seen by some as more fitting for a 'concept watch' due to its technical aesthetic.
A black dial on the Constant Escapement creates a sense of mystery, requiring close inspection and enhancing the owner's private enjoyment, while making the red-tipped seconds hand stand out.
The idea of a polished Titanium case in 44mm with the same dial as the white gold version is proposed as a perfect combination for wearability and aesthetics.
The use of Palladium for watch cases is discussed, noting its price similarity to platinum and its non-precious metal classification, with GP historically using it only in Limited Editions.

The Discussion

Alkiro1

Sep 6, 2017

I would go for the white gold version mainly because it offers a better dial contrast compared to the all black.

The "Triple bridges" are better enhanced for me. Same for the hour sub dial. Thanks for the shots of this rare and unusual timepieces dear CC. Best wishes Alkiro

crown comfort

Sep 6, 2017

Thanks Alkiro. Once again, we agree. It's clear you have good taste ;) [nt]

Alkiro1

Sep 6, 2017

Haha 😁

Great minds think alike as we use to say 😉 Best wishes Alkiro

Alkiro1

Sep 6, 2017

May be a GP Constant Escapement in palladium would have been really interesting. Less heavy than white gold and something that GP already used with the 1966 Triple Calendar for instance

I would like to see more Palladium cases today when you know that its price is almost identical to the one of the platinum and it's not considered as a precious metal 😉 Best wishes Alkiro

crown comfort

Sep 6, 2017

Hmm, Palladium would be an interesting option

so far, GP had used Pd only in Limited Editions. On the other hand, what speaks against Steel? I think it could be a good edition to Titanium and White Gold and it could lower the cost a bit.

Alkiro1

Sep 6, 2017

With such a timepiece, I think you need a very special material. In my opinion, steel is too "common" even if I'm with you about the price 😉

Best wishes Alkiro