F.P. Journe Classique: Dial Comparison Guide

Moka-Tiger (Ron) · 2021-10-31T16:19:14Z

Explore the F.P. Journe Octa Automatique vs. Octa Lune debate. Collectors weigh in on dial aesthetics, complications, and the allure of red gold.

Moka-Tiger (Ron)

WPS member · F.P. Journe forum

34 replies5704 views2 photos

Moka-Tiger (Ron), a discerning collector, initiated a compelling discussion on the F.P. Journe forum, grappling with a choice between two exquisite F.P. Journe Classique models: the Octa Automatique and the Octa Lune. His original post delves into the aesthetic nuances of each, particularly the dial's perceived 'bareness' on the Automatique versus the 'filled' look of the Lune with its moon phase complication. This exploration highlights the subtle yet significant design considerations that captivate luxury watch enthusiasts.

34 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →

I am going crazy trying to decide between 2 watches: the RG "Automatique" and the "Lune".

I prefer simple dials with easy-to-read time, so the Autmatique with blue hands and black numbers, without the "lune function" should be an easy choice. I sense that the blue hands/black numbers are THE classic Journe look. But, then, I keep wondering if the dial on the Automatique, without the lune function, looks too bare? Plus, the blue hands/numbers are pretty standard compared to the shiny gold hands and applied numbers on the Lune model. I noticed that the gold creates a much more dressy feel and luxurious look. And the lune function fills in the dial.

It's so hard to choose when all the watches are beautiful and only 1 is possible.

Actually, I chose one already and am now debating whether to choose the other one instead.

I will make the final decision in the end, when I get there.

After buying yours, do you Journe owners have any thoughts about my comments on these 2 watches?

Thanks in advance for any input.

(Pics from Journe website for showing the 2 watches.)

Below: Automatique

Below: Lune

Key Points from the Discussion

The original poster, Moka-Tiger (Ron), initially preferred the simpler Automatique dial but ultimately switched his request to the Octa Lune, finding its gold hands and applied numbers, along with the moon phase, offered more 'pizzazz' and a high-end look.
The decision between these two F.P. Journe models is highly personal, with no objectively 'wrong' choice, especially given the current difficulty in acquiring either reference. The best option is often the one immediately available or the one that truly resonates with the collector's heart.
Some collectors appreciate the moon phase complication for its practical relevance to outdoor activities and its aesthetic contribution to the dial, noting the superb detail of the moon on the F.P. Journe Lune.
The blue elements on the Octa Lune, such as the hands or moon disc, provide a desirable contrast to the red gold case and dial, enhancing its visual appeal and dressy feel.
Conversely, some enthusiasts appreciate the intentional use of empty dial space on the Octa Automatique, finding its simplicity to be a strong design statement.
Acquiring an F.P. Journe from a boutique often allows for customization, including strap color choices, with the possibility of receiving a second strap at no additional cost.

The Discussion

blau

Oct 31, 2021

Agreed.

This is DEFINITELY a 'no wrong answers' situation... but I really love the intentional use of empty dial space on the Octa dial, and that's at its strongest in the Automatique.

aperna

Oct 31, 2021

My preference would be for the lune The dial appears to be too sparse without it. Either way you can’t go wrong and I’m sure you will be extremely happy with whatever you pick

Moka-Tiger (Ron)

Nov 1, 2021

Thanks. I wrote below, but the Lune ended up being my choice. I did think the dial looked sparse without the lune function.

aperna

Nov 2, 2021

Excellent choice, congratulations

@lberti

Oct 31, 2021

The lune for sure.

Power reserve alone is taking too much space. The moonphase is a welcoming and cool complicatiom. For me clearly the second one 🤗

Gwai

Oct 31, 2021