Audemars Piguet ROO Navy vs. Elephant 42mm

glimmer · 2019-08-30T15:51:30Z

Choosing between Audemars Piguet Royal Oak Offshore 'Navy' and 'Elephant' 42mm? Collectors share pros, cons, and personal experiences to help decide.

I’ve been away from AP for a few years and have decided that it’s been missing in my collection.

I’ve narrowed it down to two choices, the ROO Navy or the ROO Elephant, both in the 42mm case diameter.

May I get your thoughts on the pros and cons of each design? I have been leaning towards the Navy because I love the blue with subtle orange accents, however the stealthiness of the Elephant is also appealing. To put it bluntly I am quite confused. Any inputs would be much appreciated.

Here are images of both:

Key Points from the Discussion

The Audemars Piguet Royal Oak Offshore 'Elephant' offers versatility, especially when paired with a bracelet, though its black lume provides less illumination in the dark.
Experiencing both the 'Navy' and 'Elephant' models in person is crucial for making an informed decision, as perceptions can change significantly after seeing them firsthand.
The 'Navy' offers a more vibrant 'pop' with its blue and orange accents, while the 'Elephant' presents a more mature and subtle aesthetic, making the choice dependent on personal style and existing collection.
The 'Elephant' is perceived as more sober, while the 'Navy' is sportier, suggesting collectors should consider what aesthetic is missing or desired in their current collection.
Some collectors find the 'Elephant' too monochromatic, questioning the appeal of a discreet-looking Offshore, which is often chosen for its bold presence.
The author ultimately chose the 'Navy' model, expressing immediate satisfaction with the purchase.

The Discussion

Chronometer (aka yacomino)

Aug 30, 2019

Both very nice, but the blue one for me for legibility! [nt]

Cpt Scarlet

Aug 30, 2019

Sorry but as a Captain it’s got to be The Navy ! [nt]

psychotic

Aug 30, 2019

The 2 are very different in nature.

I personally prefer the Navy for that added pop. But the elephant is more mature and subtle. If you can't decide, go for what kind of attire you wear the most. Also, if you already have lots of watches that already have zing to them, you may want something that is more down to earth but still have the attitude of a ROO.

glimmer

Aug 30, 2019

Most of my watches

have a somberness to them...I guess in this respect the Navy would suit me more

Kniazukay

Aug 30, 2019

Cant really go wrong here w these two choices, however...

I have the Elephant. It was my first AP. I've had it over a year now and I actually got the bracelet as well and it's a great way to have a versatile look. Let me just say though, black lume just doesn't light up great even fully charged. Then again, I just look at my phone when in the dark anyway. But I wear mostly black and gray so Elephant is what I chose and honestly my liking to the watch has grown even more the more time has gone by. Good luck on your choice and enjoy!

quattro69

Aug 30, 2019

So I guess this wasn’t on the list?

Joking aside, I love the offshore. And I highly recommend you go see and touch both watches to make the decision. I always try to do that. And I liked the elephant in person a lot more than I thought I would have.

Key Points from the Discussion

Continue the conversation

Related Articles